A good bagel is an amazing thing! I heard about Stuff a Bagel from a coworker, and it lived up to what he said, with a slight exception.I had the Frank the Tank (3 meats and egg) which was quite good, and affordable. If that was all I had, Id probably give a perfect 5 🌟.But the blueberry muffin I had was...odd. I wouldnt say it was bad, but it tasted different from every blueberry muffin Ive had before, homemade and store-bought. Wouldnt buy it again, but mostly positive feelings from my first time eating at this location.

I love this Bagel Shop. The food is great and the service is fast and friendly. I enjoyed a croissant breakfast sandwich, hashbrowns, macaroni salad, and a turkey melt with bacon. Mm mm delicious!

I don’t understand why would these people sell bagels from the day before. Instead of losing .25 cents they rather loose a customer. Zero business knowledge. I guess if you go really early they try to get rid of the bagels from the day before.

Jersey turnpike on a roll please!!! This place is awesome. Great fast service. Staff always awesome as well.

Best everything...service, 🥯, For those of us that miss a good NY/NJ style bagel..this place is a must..If youve tried the rest now try the best..5 stars not enough..We get the NJ Turpkpe.sandwich its..egg;tay.ham n cheese on an everything bagel.Delish

Liked it but i find Im the only person in there that wears a mask in there-- yes, totally get that masks are optional in Florida. Food is decent (just wished the food wasnt as greasy) & prices are good ($4.75 for a bagel sandwich). Very crowded all the times i go in mid morning.

This place has great bagels and sandwiches. So far everything we have tried has been delicious. Highly recommend.

Simple, easy, fast and delicious. Living in California, the bagels here are fluffy and much like a mediocre dinner roll - Stuff A Bagel does them right, meaning - chewy dense exterior, light and tasty inside. Just like NYC! Well done.

Always great food and friendly service. I recommend.

Was looking for a good Bagel place and found Stuff A Bagel. Very good. pleasantly surprised!

3 times in a row could not get my order right. Don’t waste your money. Imposters!!! This bagel shop claims to be “New Jersey best”, don’t embarrass NJ’s name sake.

Wait is just too long and staff is very rude. My coffee was served as regular when I asked for decaf. I watched the staffs treatment of third party delivery services that were waiting 35 min for their order. You either abide by the time promised or discontinue your agreement with them if you can’t handle the flow. It is not the delivery drivers fault. They are actually helping you get food to your loyal clientele..

Rigatoni with meat sauce and a meatball and lasagna and 3 meatballs. Fabulous!

Found a new spot! I don’t eat bagels often due to my Diabetes (T1D)But my husband loves them.. I do too.This will be a new hot spot for a treat occasionallyReally busy!Good for the young owner! Hard working young manWe know what it takes owning 4 gelaterias!

I have never been here and it seemed like the regulars move through the line fast so I told them Im new and to walk me through the selection. The lady really steered me in the right direction and was smooth. I got 13 bagels and cream cheese and it was quick. Id definitely go back. Good spot.

The place was totally amazing! I had the bagel sandwich with salmon, capers and tomatoes cream cheese! I would definitely recommend this place. The staff is very friendly and helpful!

Best place all around for bagels. Just like NY, correction even better!

I just moved from NYC ~6 months ago. One of the only things I miss about the city is the bagels. Stuff a Bagel has GREAT New York style bagels. The egg and cheese felt just like I was back in the city. Definitely recommend!! Gem in Cape Coral. Hoping they open another location closer to Pondella.

Great breakfast food. Love the Steak and egg breakfast sandwichYou need to get your breakfast on here

The front guy need to be polite and friendlyHorrible attention

This place is awesome, western omelet on an egg everything bagel was on point.

While there are many bagel shops in southwest Florida and many of them are good. However, this place is the best and probably the most authentic New York bagels in the area. They have a nice menu for options on your bagel as well as pastries, cookies, and other baked sweets. This is by far the best shop and I would highly recommend it.

Good bagle but your place Is not very clean

Used to stop here all the time till thisI understand stuff happens but on top service was rude and I understand you’re busy but there’s 3 out back not doing a thing smoking unacceptable in my opinion

Pretty good bagels...a big compliment from a Brooklyn boy!

Best NY style bagels in the Cape, I recommend to everyone especially if your from NY or NJ

Legitimately the best breakfast Ive had since living here, soo worth the wait if theres a line, family owned they know what theyre doing! Thank you for the delicious eats😘👌

One of the best bagels Ive had outside of New York. By far the best black and white cookie Ive had outside of New York. The eggs are actually fried and not microwaved like most of the other bagel shops. They make their bagels fresh throughout the day and I know this because no matter what time I go in there theyre coming out with a hot batch from the oven. Reasonably priced with a friendly staff. I wish they would go Nationwide!

Absolutely the best if youre hungry for a good morning breakfast at a reasonable price with alot of choices and a great wall of history! Bonus Yankees fans!

Im from New York and bagels in NY are so much better than Florida Ive never had a bagel here that I actually liked until I went to Stuff a Bagel this place is amazing the bagels and egg sandwiches are incredible just like NY I thank god I found this place and now I go there all the time. Its truly the best and I recommend it highly.

Great selection of Foods..Clean Environment..Reasonably PricedTruly New York Theme throughout...A+++ all around

If I wanted it toasted I would of asked for it toasted.

👏Great👏bagels 🥯 👏 🙏🏽🙌🏽

Really love this place! Perfect Long Island bagels, which is extremely hard to find outside of NY. Also EGG BAGELS!!! Fun and friendly staff. We pick up breakfast here every time we visit Cape Coral, highly recommended!!

Excellent service! Very friendly and polite. I love the food. They have many bagel options available. My favorite is the cinnamon one but today I had a I had a ham bagel. It was very good! I will be back :-)

Had a toasted everything bagel with smear. Excellent. Service was helpful and efficient. Will be returning in the future. Good bagels.

Why would I buy breakfast anywhere else?Great food, best cream cheese, fast and efficient service, awesome drink selection, and the remodel looks FANTASTIC.Oh and I didnt even mention the prices! Bought breakfast for my whole office for like $30.

Busy but quick. Bagels and cream cheese were delicious. They dont fill coffee to the top when you say black coffee.

Love this place. REAL NY bsgels - a rarity in SWFL. Intresting sandwiches on bagels or rolls including NJ Taylor ham, which is difficult to find outside NJ. Definitely a taste of home.

Great little bagel shop!

Everyone is super nice & attentive! The best cream cheese and bagels. They just remodeled and it looks great! Good prices too. Can’t go wrong with coming here.

Sold me some nasty Nova and gave me a very hard time returning it. The girl who prepared it, was the same person I returned it to, instead of apologizing was extremely rude. I Should’ve taken a picture of it.

Small but mighty. Took home 1/2 dz. Toasted up perfectly.

These guys and gals know bagels and sandwiches. Love the Taylor pork roll

Stuff A Bagel, Pine Island Rd., Cape Coral, Fl., Here is my 2 cents on the food and chatter.I was nearby and wanted something different plus sweet.So I got a raspberry danish and a reuben. About 15 bucksThe reuben with a small portion of cole slaw and a small danish tasted very good.The problem is everything is SMALL & PRICEY.I think because we are in a OVER PRICED TOURIST AREA they charge too much and the local yodels of floridians let them get away with it.

New York Bagels. Feels like your at a Long Island deli as soon as you step in. Bagels and Kaisers are perfection. Reminds me of Long Island.

Great price, service and excellent ribs

Native New Yorker and I just had my first bagel and lox at Stuff A Bagel. It was beyond fantastic. Highly recommended.

1st time visit and definitely not the last, bagels were fresh and still warm. There was a line but worth the wait.

I’ve been coming here for a few years now. It’s been awhile because I wasn’t sure if they’d be open or not.. I’m about to get some this morning and I can’t wait! Always so delicious and fresh.

I love the lox spread! And their lox! Only place that I can find it in the Cape!

Great bagels and bagel sandwiches. The cream cheeses here are worth every penny. For a guy from up north, the NY/NJ charm from the staff and establishment make it feel like home.

Fast friendly service with awesome bagels and love their specialty cream cheeses.

One of my all-time favorite places to eat for the past 25 years. I like all the friendly atmosphere of everyone when I go in there not only the employees oftentimes customers, everyone friendly conversations going on about mainstream topics. I cant relate their food to anywhere else definitely the best! Just wished I lived closer so we could spend more time here.

Twice now back to back ordered bacon egg and cheese sandwich on everything bagel toasted. Bagel not toasted twice now and last time was 15 minutes out On a call in arrived and sandwich not done get to the car bagel not toasted They have fun but don’t pay attention to detail. Wonder how much food they waste with wrong orders. Next time I’m returning mine. Never had a problem before

Good restaurants in the Cape are few and far between, but weve finally found a go-to breakfast place. Everything here is super fresh from the bagels to the salmon and even their juices. The prices are very reasonable and the staff is very friendly and accommodating. Well definitely be back!

Stuff a bagel 🥯 then eat it was gooood

My favorite place in Lee county. I walk in, and instantly am brought back home to New Jersey. Their bagels are on point, the exact way someone from NY or NJ would expect. The staff are HARD WORKING! I appreciate them so much for all they do. I hope this business runs strong and long!Please grab a bagel with cream cheese from here before you to to work, or before a walk around town or on the beach. It will make your day, and if youre like me, it will bring you back in time.

Best begals ive had in a while.Everything and Asiago were my favorite

Bagels are legit ! Nice selection of Breakfast and Lunch sandwiches ! First time there will definitely be back !

Best bagels in town! Nj turnpike is amazing! Definitely going to be my go to bagel spot from now on.

Their cousin Vinny is a stud!

Bagels were good but pricey

The food is probably excellent but we turned around when we saw the staff without a mask. Not a safe place to eat

We love it here. Not just for the bagles but also for the complete breakfast meals you can order!

Love their bacon egg and cheese on everything. Love love love this place. GREAT everytime!!

Best Bagels ib town. Tuesday special gets you 18 for the price of a dozen. Breakfast sandwiches and the usual breakfast beverages. Helpful nice staff. I visit this place with regularity.

As close as youre gonna get to bagels from back home in Queens ,Brooklyn or long island....plus they have N.Y. Mets memorabilia up on the walls. 5 stars for this area ...

Love their food and the staff is always super friendly. My only issue is that calling in to order, when I don’t come in, is VERY tough sometimes as they do not answer the phone.

I love this place always have and I have never had a bad experience.

I have heard lots of good things about this place so I wanted to give it a try. Everything I wanted they didnt have so I tried a bagle with cream cheese and it was disgusting. Bought a cappuccino with flavor and no flavor was added and the cup wasnt even full and it was $4 I could have gone to any chain spent less and had better food. Very disappointing 😕. Even the staff wasnt very welcoming or pleasant. I felt like I was bothering them for walking in . It was very uncomfortable.

Never disappoints 👍😋👍

Love this place ! Im from Jersey and cant find good Taylor Ham go here and they make the best taylor ham egg and cheese on an everything bagel ! Yummy

Great bagels better service.

Food is so good service is to match. A daily must to start my day..

Everytime i go there, i get the jersey turnpike and man it just seems to get better everytime even when it seems impossible. 11/10. Highly recommended place to eat. Awesome staff and amazing food. 👍🏼

We’ve been eating here for years now but we won’t be coming back again any time soon... I’ve had 2 orders completely messed up the last 2 times I’ve come in... the same woman took both orders and we went over it several times to be sure we got it right on both sides because I usually order more the 4 things and I understand it can get confusing but both times we were reassure the order was what it was supposed to be.. when we called back the same woman answered the phone and we told her what was wrong and she got rude with my wife over the phone saying “what do you want me to do about?” With a snippy tone that I could even here from across the table... maybe some training is in order for her to understand how to treat customers properly and how to remember orders.. Joey please address her..

Being from the north east originally Ive had my share of good bagels and I know what authentic NY style bagels look and taste like. That being said, this is certainly a spot where you can get such a bagel. Service is quick and good with the bagels being top notch. I highly recommend Stuff a Bagel for a good Jersey Turnpike special.

They put so much cream cheese on a bagel is not even funny, absolutely love it

NEw Yorkers knows NY make the best bagels.The staff once’s lived LI, NY.Came in and staff awesome eating their food felt I’m was back in home. Toasted sesame bagel with extra butter and their bacon, egg and cheese on a roll with delicious.

Best bagels I’ve ever had- amazing. Good people working there too! Awesome

Good bagel breakfast..

Food great,Parking sucks!

Got more then we needed. Love those bagels.

Best breakfast in town

Very fresh bagels and a friendly staff, great place for some breakfast! 😁

The bagels are always so GOOD! The different kinds of spreads are amazing too. If you dont get there early enough most of the bagels will be gone.

Staff is awesome! Food is always great!

Bagels are very good. They have a decent selection of bagels. Also some muffins and pastries. I had the everything egg bagel. First place Ive seen this kind of bagel since being in New York. Good selection of cream cheese flavors also. I recommend.

Excellent quality and service. Best in the area!

Love this place the NJ. Turnpike is a taste of home. Mmmm pork roll!

Everytime I visit the Cape I make sure to get 2 toasted bagels. Theyre so delicious!

Wife and I went out of our way to snag a couple authentic bagels (we are from Detroit) while in the Cape Coral area. We arrived near closing time and got the deal of our lives, as they were happy to give us a few freebies that would otherwise be wasted. Hats off to the crew. BTW these homemade bagels were fabulous!

Real New York style bagels, right here in Cape Coral! Bagels are light and fluffy as apparently they bake them daily. Had the bacon egg & cheese and a coffee which they pride themselves on fresh and hot coffee. Seating is a bit limited, so get there early because they are always busy, but the staff is always rushing around to get you served. Always worth the 3-5 minutes it takes to get thsese amazing local bagels.

I love the staff I love the owners they are all very friendly. The bagels are made fresh. There’s no reason to look any further this is the best bagel in SWFL. Thanks for bringing New York style bagels to Florida.

Do delicious! Quick friendly service

The best bagels in swfl served by the most attentive and kind employees around. theyre working hard and im so grateful that even during a pandemic when everything feels uncertain, i know at least that i can always come here for a delicious breakfast made fresh. thank you for all you do 🥯

Awesome bagels and service! Love the veggie cream cheese. Cant beat the great prices either. Cant wait to try one of their breakfast specials.

Great place to get NY style bagels....just be prepared. The lines may be long. (Thats a good thing )

They serve amazing bagels here! Food is always fresh.. Bagels always fresh.. Pastries always fresh & delicious. The service is AMAZING. True- NY style bagels. When I go there it feels like I am back in my old town. Also having lived in N.Y. for half of my life- this is without a doubt the next best thing to NY bagels you will find in all of Lee County/ SWFL. Highly recommended!!