Amazing cookie dough, but what’s even better was my husband ordered my birthday cake from here.It is heavenly! The bottom layer was Oreo, with a layer of cookie dough and then topped with ice cream and scoops of cookie dough! It was so good. I got espresso and I will be getting an ice cream cake from here for all of my special occasions. Also I believe the owner who I think we spoke to is a very nice man and super helpful!

Their cookie dough is very good. You also get a lot of it. If you just want a snack get the mini. If you want to share with others get a bigger size. I went with my two daughters and we each got a flavor so we could taste different ones. The smores was our favorite and the brownie was excellent too. The chocolate chip cookie dough was good but the others were better.

The ice cream cookie sandwich was delicious! 😋

OK feels to be the right words for this place. Its ice cream and cookie dough. Thats what you get. Nothing crazy unique or special about this place.FOODThe ice cream is good... just not blow your socks off, something to write home about good.Given the culture of today, I was shocked they didnt offer a gluten free cookie dough option. I cannot remember the last time I walked into a place and didnt have a gluten free option. Just for that reason, Id make an effort to go to another sweet spots for some gluten free topping.SPACEAgain, emphasizing nothing really stood out. There isnt a ton of character about this place. Its not bad, by all means. Just not cute or memorable. If I had a choice to take an out-of-towner here, Id think of another spot.

We were in early evening on a Saturday. They were out of most baked cookies for their sandwiches so I had to get 2 different cookies, which I could deal with just fine! But,the plain choco chip cookie dough I asked for in the middle was just....not....right. It had too much or too little of something, but I ended up tossing most of it as did others in my party. Baked Sugar cookie was decent. Double Chocolate, dont suggest....didnt taste like much. Other dessert options in the area that are superior.

This place has a special place in our hearts! We absolutely love the cookie dough flavors and we make sure to visit EVERY time were in the area. The outdoor seating was a nice change from our last visit 4 years ago.

I came here with several other friends, and we all got different flavors to try out. Dont overestimate: we found that the smallest size is more than enough for 2-3 people, as the cookie dough is very (almost too) sweet and filling.The cookie dough here is really creamy, unlike other cookie doughs Ive tried. Chocolate Chip and M & M are the most creamy out of the flavors we tried, being similar to a peanut-butter consistency, what wasnt expected. Fudge brownie and smores are more grainy, which I personally liked more.Great service and staff! They have caps you can snap on top of your containers, to easily take home.

1st time here and was not disappointed. Icecream 🍦 was absolutely delicious 😋Portion size was perfectCustomer service was very friendly n kind!!

Not how I remember it... I havent been here in about 10 years, and I was pretty disappointed. When I lived closer I used to come literally almost everyday and I remember the ice cream being much better, almost like a gelato, now its pretty much just like cold stone ice cream, nothing special. And they didnt have the zanzibar dark chocolate that I used to love. The cookie dough is exactly how I remember it though, its pretty good. The other thing was the horrible loud music. I dont recommend and will never go back...

Yummy! Get the cookie dough topping of your choice. Its a game changer!!

Given this place a few tries. Cookie dough is ok but tastes a little off (mass produced?) and has a strange consistency. Cant eat a ton of it before feeling like its too much. Store ambiance is a little rough around the edges for downtown Naperville and has not changed the few years Ive been. I think the cookie dough at cinnaholic is more genuine.

As many reviews state, the owner is rude. The cookie dough is not fresh, but stored - he said. He called me Karen after I told him I would write a review.

Amazing cookie dough! Been going here for years!

Get the cookie dough sandwiches. I promise you will not be disappointed. Btw 1 sandwich can feed multiple people

Was walking by here on a fall night last night, couldn’t pass by without stopping in for a mini treat, I got moose tracks ice cream with Oreo cookie dough & I will defiantly recommend to friends & family! I will be back to try other flavors, the shop is cute & friendly, places to sit & enjoy!

Nice selection of cookie dough and ice cream flavors. Reasonable prices. Smores cookie dough is perfect, not too sweet.

So good, so rich I could not finish my ice cream

Amazing cookie dough! They also have ice cream and shakes. So happy I found this place ☺️

We visited here for the edible cookie dough, and were not disappointed! I had the cake batter cookie dough and my husband had the m&m cookie dough, and they were both so delicious! We ordered size small in waffle cones, and wished we ordered the mini size! It is very filling, but definitely worth it. Can’t wait to come back here!

Amazing. Great ice cream.

Ordered some ice cream and cookie dough combo via Grubhub and was delighted to see all the great reviews were true! Absolutely loved the Anniversary cake ice cream and the cake batter cookie dough. My husband loved his vanilla ice cream and chocolate chip cookie dough. Will definitely be ordering more sweet treats from here again -- highly recommend!!

By far my favorite ice cream place ever! I have moved out of state, come back, moved to the city, now in the NW Suburbs and I STILL go out of my way for ice cream here. The cookie dough is the best! Just a small place and totally worth a drive to get here. We brought a cooler to have it travel safely back home (45mins away).

My girlfriend and I have recently fallen in love with this place. We play darts and spend about an hour here! Great portions for the price and a great product too. One of my favorite places on the planet to be completely honest.

MUST TRY! I been going there for years. The quality has been amazing since day one. Many many flavors for all types of taste buds. Employees are very helpful and knowledgeable. Definitely try it even if cookie dough is not your thing.

Nothing special but still a good place for ice cream

Cookie dough taste terrible, just buy the new store one. this is made with far far far to much butter. Also theres a new place in naperville with vastly superior cookie dough now this place is far overated. Just because its been in town for so long they need to wake up call soon.

Delicious ice cream!

Cookie dough is great. Entrance needs to be accessible. Those with wheelchairs, like me, cant enter the building.

Had this place once before and I got the best of both worlds ice cream and cookie dough talk about amazing!

Cookie dough taste terrible, just buy the new store one. This one is made with far far far to much butter. Also theres a new place in Naperville with vastly superior cookie dough now this place is far overated. Just because its been in town for so long they need a wake up call soon.

Get to Cookie Dough Creations right now! Class A People! Yummy ice cream and cookie dough. Always friendly, always delicious!!!

Soooo good....and i recommend to get any ice cream with the dough because it kinda makes your throat dry and the ice cream makes it less dry but other than that super good 👍😇I hope u try it.

Great place to go and the cookie dough is amazing. Fun place to stop with your family. If youre getting cookie dough by itself you probably only need their smallest size since its so rich.For the employees and owner. Maybe staff a but better so your employees arent so short with a family who doesnt know what they want and want to try a few flavors. Instead of asking them if theyre ready maybe make suggestions or offer advice?

I love their cookie dough but my husband went in tonight to pick up a treat and employee had no mask on! As of May 1st its required and they know better! If handling peoples food you should definitely have a mask on!

Best cookie dough in Chicagoland

Yes. Yes. Yes. Cookie Dough Creations is worth the trip. This is anniversary cake ice cream with M&M cookie dough!

Staff was great, but their cookie dough is a hard pass. Literally threw mine out because it tasted... Weird. Not like any cookie dough Ive had before.

All employees present were teenagers interested in their own needs not the customers. Glad I was with someone that had been there before. Also been nice if I could have had an opportunity to test taste a few options before I made a purchase. Several employees available but none seemed interested in helping.

Its definitely a cool experience. Dont know that Id do it again. You dont get that much cookie dough, mostly ice cream. And you have to pay for bottled water. They were quick and kind though.

Place was nice, but we were all pretty disappointed by the cookie dough. Very very mushy and way too sweet. Staff also looked like they could care less about serving us and just wanted us to get out

Amazing family owned spot, some of the best human beings you will ever meet and the ice cream/cookie dough is awesome too!!!

Their chocolate chip cookie dough was the best. My niece liked it so much that I have to promise to be back here with her. Staffs were super friendly too.

A great small business. Friendly staff. Helpful when a delivery service didnt pick up my order. Outstanding customer service.

Had to try this and Im craving it all the time now.

Great for anyone with a sweet tooth. It’s very filling and at a great price!

This cute little shop has the most delicious edible cookie dough. Every single flavor is delicious! Try with or without ice cream! Id recommend a mini size if youll just eat the dough, as it is quite rich and filling.

Absolutely love cookie dough over any other ice cream/frozen yogurt place downtown. The serving sizes are HUGE! Ice cream tastes amazing, but you must try it with the cookie dough as well. Id recommend this place to anybody who hasnt already tried it.

Absolutely the best cookie dough Ive ever had in my life. But if you are allergic to some of the ingredients in cookie dough, they dont tell you everything they use. However, I would definitely go there again.

This place is one of my all time favorite places to go in the area and every time I look forward to it. They recently added a back room which has old style Pac-Man games and a place to eat your amazing cookie dough. The prices are a bit high but u get a lot and it fills you up fast. The employees are fast and do their job flawlessly. Definitely recommend this place to anyone looking for cookie dough that doesn’t contain eggs and tastes great, how much better can u get.

Unbelievably great

Great time here. Thanks for a great place to hang out with friends. Love the arcade games in the back.

I wouldnt eat a big dinner and then go here. Or if you do, order the smallest size because you get a decent amount of both ice cream AND cookie dough. Not complaining, just wasnt expecting so much. They recently took the tables out (per another patron), but that might be because it is winter. Was told there was an arcade in the back room but didnt see that due to the adjacent bar using it for a private party.

Really friendly and great staff, with a cute atmosphere. There are lots of options with the cookie dough, but unfortunately I found the taste to be just average. The ice cream was what won me over. Great place to take kids or visiting family as a novelty. Would be a great spot to finish out a day in downtown Naperville.

Delicious cookie dough. I think the recipe was changed somewhat recent and its much more creamy now. We got the chocolate chip cookie dough in the kids size and it was plenty for my wife and I!

Ice cream with cookie dough and a cookie on top in January in Naperville? Yes please! The cold doesnt bother me as a Midwesterner. Cookie Dough Creations is a staple of downtown Naperville! May I recommend the Matt Larson Fudge Delight as I call it: 2 scoops mocha almond fudge ice cream, 1 scoop of fudge brownie cookie dough batter and a double chocolate cookie. Im drooling just thinking about it! Summer or winter, youll see Matt Larson digging in at CDC. Hope to see you there!

Ice cream and cookie dough together, a sweet mix. They’ve got many flavors of both and all are good. The mint chip ice cream with the brownie cookie down was a great combination.

A cute ice cream store, with a twist, in a cute area. If you are a fan of cookie dough then this place, with various flavors, will be your new favorite ice cream store. I recommend asking the workers what flavors will pair well together if you aren’t sure. Enjoy!

Great little spot, usually busy but nothing excessive. The niche of putting the cookie dough on the ice cream is wonderful. Our kids love going here and even my wife and I will stop by on date night for a couple scoops. Highly recommend.

The brown sugar cookie dough with a side of ice cream is the best! The lines can be long, but staff moves quickly to serve everyone. Plenty of seating in the back room.

Amazing ice cream and ice cream sandwiches!

This place is awesome! Sometimes I wish I could just buy a ton of the cookie dough and eat it for hours . . . But, the cookie is sooo rich, you NEED the Ice cream to balance it out. Plus, the sizes are HUGE. Be careful what you order!

Cookie dough is a cup then add ice cream! Done!

Loved the concept, but DO NOT get the cookie dough without ice cream to cut down the sweetness. I will be back!

Delicious ice cream! Plenty of choices for base ice cream flavors, complemented by your choice of a variety of raw (egg free) cookie dough! Process is easy and the service is quick and friendly. Id highly recommend this place for after dinner desert for a walk on the Naperville river walk!

What a great idea! Icecream and Cookie dough. I wish we had this business in my home town.

I would die of diabetes if I lived closer. Everything there was delicious. Love the concept as a whole.

I used to stop by this little shop every time I passed through Naperville. The past couple times that I visited, I was really disappointed in the quality of food. The cookies were way too thick and very hard. Don’t waste your money :/

We seek out Cookie Dough Creations for their delicious cookie dough! I dont know of any other place around that serves cookie dough like this! They have great ice cream too so mix and match!

I love this place but the last time I went here the man serving my ice cream was sweating like he had a fever, wiped his running nose with his hand, wiped it on his pants and served the next customer. I hope this is not a common occurrence. If management is seeing this the man was about 5’9, brown hair on top of his head thinning, heavier set. Time and date/ 12/30/18 9:25pm

Every flavor of ice cream and cookie dough is excellent. Great selection of sizes for any appetite. Always worth the trip.

The food was good. We got a combo ice cream and cookie dough waffle cone for $5.75. We got a full waffle cone of ice cream and one cookie scoop sized scoop of Cooke dough. The ice cream was good, however, we will probably not be going back.

Super cute shop and a ton of options to choose from! There were a variety of cookie dough flavors!

The ice cream was very good the atmosphere was nice to really enjoyed it

Not impressed so far. Drove an hour here website says opens at 10:00. Its 10:15 doors are locked. A lady comes up to open the door says sorry we dont open til 11:00. I said your website says 10:00. She says theres nothing they can do about that and continues Im the shop and locks doors behind her. I will get the cookie dough this time but I am NOT impressed so far. As a business owner myself customers come first. Friendliness goes along way.

It had great employees but I really wasnt a huge fan of the cookie dough.

My kid is an extremely cookie dough fan... She was in cookie dough heaven... Its a very nice place for your cookie dough fan..

Unless you’re sharing there’s no need to go large. The dough here is very good but it took me over an hour to finish the mid-size I got so I could try multiple flavors.

Unless you’re sharing there’s no need to go large. The dough here is very good but it took me over an hour to finish the mid-size I got so I could try multiple flavors.

A unique gut ache waiting to happen. I mean that in a good way, because it is so tasty you will eat more sugar than your system can handle. Cookie dough + ice cream. And who doesnt love cookie dough?

Our 1st time at this store . We had pizza at Lou’s and wanted something sweet for dessert, my kids wanted the cookie dough and ice cream so we stopped at sweet creations.We started walking back to our car while eating the ice cream. Half way thru my son found a long blonde hair in his cup of ice cream and dough. I’ve never had this happen ever at an ice cream place, but I guess it can happen anywhere . I wish that all places serving food would wear hair nets and have at least one adult on the premises to look after the teenagers that don’t always follow rules of sanitation. There’s nothing worse than enjoying your food only to get half way done and finding a strangers hair in your food. I didn’t take it back cause there were no adults working it might have been useless. I just hope the owners adopt the habit of hair nets moving forward. It can’t hurt.

I dont understand why they dont have dairy-free options. The cookie dough is egg-free, if they would make it without dairy milk, they could have vegan options. My sisters and I came here and they both could not finish their cookie dough. If you come, order a small size (unless you eat large quantities of cookie dough at home on the regular).

Good pallet of ice creams with a proper portion size

Holy shnikeys - this place is incredible. Best dessert place Ive ever been to. Great service. Will definitely be back.

Good variety of ice cream and cookie dough. Great service. Love the new seating area.

Great ice cream and sweets and an 80s vintage arcade in the back.

Cookie dough and ice cream. What could be better? Friendly staff and great desserts. Worth checking out if you are in Naperville looking for a sweet treat. I would pick the mint ice cream with chocolate chip cookie dough

Really delicious but really rich! I definitely couldnt eat more than a small combo but they have a great product!

Great Ice-cream place, cookie dough is awesome. They really need to change the sizes. Small is really Large.😀😀😀. Highly recommended.

Great as always. Been enjoying this place for years!

Tasty experience overall. It was all extremely rich and hard to eat though (even a small)

This hole in the wall is a cookie monsters dream. The key is the desire for cookie dough. Yes, there is ice cream but it is the icing on the c(ookie)ake not the focal point.Here are a few tips and tries:First Trip: get a large bowl and have them put a little from all eight of the cookie dough. This is a perfect size for 4 people. You can have a scoop of ice cream at the bottom - killer combination!Gotta Have: Cookie Dough Milkshake. Wow! Keep it simple: chocolate chip (I do extra because I like it thicker) with vanilla ice cream. Perfect!Take Home: Cookie Dough Sandwich. I love the sugar cookie cake batter!Final Tip: there ice cream is good but dont go there solely for that or youll wonder what all the hype is about.

New decor is great. Seems like less cookie dough flavors

Cookie dough is delicious mixed with the ice cream. The cookie dough by itself is just as good as well.

The food here is good. And there isn’t a place like this around. But it grosses me out how dirty the place is. Makes you not want to eat there

Love this place! Cookie dough is always a hit with my family and we make it a tradition when we go downtown naperville to make sure and stop for some ice cream with cookie dough on top

This is the yummiest treat in Naperville! Most amazing way to eat cookie dough ice cream! Fast & Friendly service... So fun that they are open late!

Raw dough is fantastic and there are multi flavors to choose from.

Interested in trying other combos, but overall it was better than I expected. I got the mini size and it was plenty, very rich ice cream and cookie dough

The cookie dough and ice cream are a great combination with huge serving sizes no matter what you get. Can get pretty packed inside but the mass usually moves pretty quickly.

Delicious ice cream and cookie dough and big portion sizes for the price!