The only option for gelato if you cant go to Italy to get it. The gelato is perfection. The espresso and cappuccino are exceptional. And the random imported treats that bring me back to my childhood summers are the final piece to a perfect outing.

Amazing little hidden Italian gem! Had great selection of self-made smooth, decadent and refreshing gelatos and sorbets. Great selection of hot and cold coffee drinks as well. I so wish this place was closer to us. I also wish the owner would contact me so I can co-invest with him on a few other locations... there is a huge need for gelatos on certain areas of LI! Do not wait and pass this place by.

I am not one to write reviews for places in general, but I had to show love to my favorite coffee place of all time. I have tried a countless amount of coffee shops on the island and I must say that I am lucky my favorite one is the closest to me. Quite honestly, nothing else compares. I have been going here for about a year and I have never been disappointed. Love you guys!!

There is NO BETTER Gelato anywhere on Long Island.. Great staff, OH how could I not mention the espresso, Incredible**..

I finally had a chance to stop by today and wonder why it took this long. I got a medium limetta and it was better than I could have hoped. I have loved lime since I was a kid and couldn’t pass up the the flavor. I don’t care what anyone says, gelato is far superior to ice cream.

Fantastic cappuccino, good tiramisu, and the lady making/serving them is very nice and friendly. While we were there a guy came in who seemed to be the place owner.. and he didnt seem very nice. But I dont think he interacts with the customers.

Best Gelato Ive ever had

Cute little café. Yummy gelato and hot cocoa.

Delicious gelato, made fresh with ingredients from Italy.

BEST HOMEMADE FRESH GELATO! They have their signature flavors but they have fresh new flavors like today hade rainbow cookie gelato. They have the best tiramisu, biscotti and other great desserts. Cafe Italia is their own little Italy. Theres indoor and outdoor seating. I highly recommend trying them out if you havent already. Always friendly staff.

Best gelato and ice coffee in long Island .

It’s like a little piece of Italy. IEnjoyed it very much

Excellent gelato, nice place

Great Gelato, many flavors.

Best Gelato I have ever tried Awesome cappuccino delicious cannolis

Pleasant service and delicious gelato!

Highly recommended, the gelato and cannolis were amazing and very authentic!

Ask for Tony, unassuming little man who is full of life and is part of the experience.The best dessert place on Long Island that I have been to. It’s a small shop but you feel like Charlie bucket.Gelato are amazing and always a new flavor to try.We love you Tony, we will be back from Texas.

Cute little underrated cafè. It’s hard to find good Italian bakeries or coffee shops or supermarkets around but this cafe is pretty good. The espresso and gelato are a must have obviously and there are good imported coffee’s to buy :)

Excellent Gelato! Random stop here after a bit of House hunting. Small shop with 10 or 12 varieties of Gelato, we tried 5 different and all had great pure flavor, whether it was Hazelnut, Dark & Milk Choc. Etc.

Desserts are excellent.

Only THE BEST!!!👍👍👍

Delicious ice cream and great flavor choices. A must try in Deer Park.

Great Gelatos!

Literally love this place. the man who served us (name unknown possibly tony) the cutest in the freaking world. we called to find out when they closed and this man WAITED for us to get there just for him to then serve us this DELICIOUS gelato, while also cracking jokes and being a absolute sweetie at the SAME TIME. also might i mention he is HUSTLING during a global pandemic. the world doesn’t deserve this place OR this spectacular man!! 10/10 will be back again

THIS IS A GREAT PLACE FOR FRESH GELATO, ESPRESSO AND SOME AWESOME ITALIAN TREATS.

I love this place! Real, authentic Italian to die for Gelato! The best milkshakes and cappuccino! My fave is the affogato! The atmosphere is always warm, welcoming and friendly. The owner Michael makes you feel right at home. You can sit down and enjoy your cup of espresso or bakery items while listening to Italian music and feel like you are in a gelateria right in the heart of Italy. He imports all of his ingredients and merchandise straight from Italy as well so you know its the real deal! Highly recommended!

Authentic Italian coffee shop that’s very rare on the Island now!They have gelato, pastries, coffee, paninis, snacks and a tiny little grocery for imported Italian stuff. I tried a cappuccino and some gelato (Gianduia and Whiskey Cream) and both were delicious.Someone mentioned no mask-wearing in a prior review, everyone inside was wearing them properly when I went so idk.

Great Sorbet!!

Love them!! Best gelato in North Babylon! These are the only Italian ice creams my family and I have. They are just delicious! These are the only ones I would cheat on my diet any day😋

Great gelato and affogato. I also had a slice of the rainbow cake and it was flavorful. I love that this place is open late and has the traditional italian-style treats and goodies for sale as well. Prices are fair and parking is always easy. No complaints at all, recommended!

Very tasty gelato! Just like Italy

Really wonderful little caffe with gelato and snacks. Very pleasant experience with nice people. Has become my favorite place to go for gelato even though its 20 minutes away.

The Gelato is always delicious and very well made - and the staff are always lovely!!

Great coffee, nice staff, delicious croissants, awesome gelato! Cant have starbucks coffee after discovering this sweet place

What a precious place. The people who work their are so nice! I went in for Gelato. They have more new flavors on daily basis. They will offer them to you to try! Friendly and clean!

Staff are always friendly, food is top notch and authentic. Great place to go to finish the night, or just to treat yourself to amazing gelato!

Great Gelato made on the premises!

Stopped here on a whim on the way to somewhere else for my daughters birthday. She really wanted to try it. Were really glad we did.Nice gelato and Italian coffee shop. Staff was friendly. The gelato was rich and creamy, you can tell they make it there. Our favorite was actually the Italian vanilla. Everyone has had vanilla ice cream in their life but I have to say its probably the best vanilla Ive ever had. Creamy and full of flavor.Great place well definitely be back.

Must try is their Affogato (gelato with a shot of espresso). We tried this this little gem first time with my family this weekend. Their homemade gelato is decadent and just the right amount of sweetness.

Beat Gelato and espresso. Staff is friendly. allot of good treats

Best damn gelato!! Pretty sure they know my order by now! So good. I recommend the chocolate, cappuccino, espresso, and the stracatella! All great

I really like what they offer. The food and beverages are great and meticulously prepared. The staff is usually very friendly. But there is this one employee, Mike, very rude and uninviting. I hope he changes his attitude.

Stopped by to get some coffee and ended up getting some amazing gelato! They let you try before picking your flavor. Best gelato we ever had! The service was wonderful as well! Next time will try their fresh pastries. Highly recommend!

I love this place so much. The veggie panini is great, all the lattes i have tried are great and the gelato is delicious

Very good Ice cream,many flavors. Nice people

Staff was extremely nice and the cannolis were great

Such a cute place!

Best place in Town for Your Caffe...

Awesome service, I only got a gelato this time and it was amazing! The price wasnt too bad either. Im definitely going back to try the coffee and canolis.

This is a great little place with owners from Italy. The espresso was good the few times Ive gone

This is the best little authentic italian coffee shop! I love it! A gem for the neighborhood with the best home made real italian gelato I ever had, OMG try the rum raisan soooooo Good! The staff there are very friendly and made me feel so welcome like Im a regular customer. So if you love authentic places and you love a really good cup of cappuccino and the best gelato ever come here you must try this little long island gem.

I had gone there last night to pick up pastries for a party, I got some homemade cannolis and some pastries from inside the glass case. The cannolis were actually fantastic, but the pastries were awful, they were dry, they have an aftertaste, they tasted old. Like someone sprayed them with hairspray. It was embarrassing at the party and I wouldnt recommend their pastries to anyone.The girl at the service counter, was actually very sweet and fantastic so no judgment on her.

I love this place...all sorts of Italian specialty desserts, nice people, a very unusual place. Their gelato is delicious!

Great gelato, very nice servers, have been many times, lots of different flavors. Pistachio is amazing

Best espresso on this side of the pond. Gelato is good too!

Great place. Authentic Gelato and great stuff from Italy. Everything tastes amazing!!

Great gelato and clean store. No complaints

Some of the most amazing gelato I have ever had on Long Island. Import products from Italy and high quality service. Best gelato/coffee shop on Long Island!

Delicious gelato. Legit gelato, not just ice cream given a fancy name. Hazelnut and pistachio and espresso are amazing!

Great little cafe....all you favorite italian deserts and coffees....they even speak Italian......FRESH cannoli filling....I ate a few....other deserts were just as fresh... ...we will be back

Stopped in one day and brought me back to Italy. Gelato was yummy.

Good coffee always fresh Oh yeah and great Treats☕🍪🍰🍦

Price found online (Doordash) was incorrectly lowered. The gelato was fantastic and they had a plethora of options. They also have many Italian snacks and cakes along with some lunch options, such as fresh cannoli and tirimisu.Staff was very friendly and made sure I was taken care of.

So friendly and the gelato is delicious. Love this place!

The place is great to have coffee and a pastry workers excellent the service is great gelatos delicious amazing unbelievable people should go there more

Very good. Better than Starbucks.

Best Gelato on Long Island Hands Down!!! I should know Im Italian 🇮🇹 🤓

What a unique idea to open an authentic Italian gelato / pastry coffee shop centrally located in a town that has been primarily Italian for 60 plus years. DOH!!! Why the hell didnt I think of it. This place could be plopped in the middle of little Italy and people would flock to it. Not that there is much of little Italy left. Got there around 8:00 after a great dinner just down the street. Very small place a few tables along one wall and 2 small tables outside. 3 of us ordered coffee and gilatos and grabbed one of the outdoor tables. By the time we got half way through the line was literally out the door. Tried to take a picture but battery in my phone died as I hit the button. Many Italian speaking people, it reminded me of my aunt Sarahs kitchen when our big family was over for dinner. Dont know what to say except GO!!!!!

The best Gelato on the Island... A small place with great taste!

The staff is very friendly and kind, the gelato and pastries are to die for. Gelato tastes exactly like the gelato in Italy.

Best place in Deer Park for GREAT gelatin and Wonderful Italian conversation all while sitting outside under the stars Like in ROME ala piazza!! Morto Buono,

Great little place - friendly - delicious gelato 😀Three years later and my family has fallen in love with Caffe Italia. Honestly their gelato is authentic, and so are they. You can feel the Italian warmth from them when they wait on you, and they’re happy to make you part of the family. ♥️

Unique gelato flavors. So delicious!

Hidden Gem. Great gelato and coffee

One of the best gelatos you could find around

Lovely small coffee shop, good coffee and homemade gelato everyday.The gelato here is amazing - pistachio and hazelnut are my favorites.There is a pumpkin gelato right now that is off the charts.This is the best gelato on Long Island.

Ahhhhmazing!! The freshest, most delicious gelato weve ever had!! (My girlfriends niece spent a week in Italy last year and she says this is just as good.)Twelve flavors of gelato. All homemade using the finest ingredients. Three or four were usually made fresh that morning.While the flavors do change (somewhat) youll almost always find Nutella, Espresso, Cookies & Cream, and Lemon.Espresso is my personal favorite! My girlfriends favorite is the strawberry cheesecake (thats a flavor of gelato, not a cheesecake).The owner is as nice as can be. In fact, everyone that works their is exceptionally nice.This is not a full-service restaurant. Its a dessert place.In addition to gelato they have coffee, tea, espresso, and cappuccino. Ive had the cappuccino twice. Outstanding!Finally, they have Italian pastries - including cannoli they fill when ordered. (No soggy pastry here!)If youre in the Deer Park area and youre looking for an exceptional dessert to satisfy your sweet tooth, Caffé Italia is the place!!!CHI MANGIA BENE, MANGIA ITALIANO!!! :-)

Nice gelato selection

Fabulous, authentic Italian gelato - just like in Rome.Try the pistachio or the baci (chocolate/hazelnut).If you have never had real italian gelato you must try this.Its a thousand times better than any ice cream.

Real Italian gelato

Friendly staff and best gelato on Long Island.

Cute little place that offers the taste of Italy

Gelato to die for!!!

A little nostalgia in Deer Park,, good coffee and gelato

Cant get a better gelato. Authentic! Just like in Italia.

Excellent Gelato, Excellent Coffee

Amazing gelato and great service!

Wild berry cheese was excellent

Very good gelato.

Excellent gelato and great cappuccinos

Coffee here is amazing!

Best coffee place ever

Very good gelato

Great gelato!

I’m there for their authentic gelatos

Very good ,the Best!!

Good :-)

Great spot

Yummy