Visiting Long Island from Florida with my girlfriend. She took me to my first deli. DUDE… IT’S SO GOOD!! SO WORTH THE WAIT. The line was seriously 40+ people but we waited and it was super worth it. Super friendly staff too taking the orders. 10 out of 5 stars

They are fast here so be ready to order! That being said their Bec was tasty!

This is by far the most incredible bagel place I’ve ever been to. I moved out of smithtown recently and didn’t get the opportunity to order every weekend for delivery anymore ! I finally came back to visit family & had to stop by . If you’re looking for a clean & delicious bagel place to eat at , this is the place ! The staff has the rush down pat with a flawless system to have orders out efficiently . I wish I could give this place 10 stars ! Well done guys

Excellent selection of bagels, and I can say they’re a perfect example of what a New York bagel should be. Their jalapeño cream cheese is awesome, but spicy, if you like that. Also have today, their macaroni salad is top notch. All around great place, love it.

Wow Fresh Food! Great options! I never knew this little gem was hidden right here in plain site! Loved loved the salad checklist starting with tuna and egg salad on top, add tomatoes peppers onions cucumber dressing many different options, meat on top of course for the carnivores like me, point is it was healthy felt good taste better & I went in there to get a egg bagel cheese bacon breakfast sandwich 🥪 my girlfriend did and that was also terrific I know because I stole a bite. What youll love is the freshness of the product fast high turnover thats how you know youre getting good food.

Great, fresh food - with such a courteous staff.

Sydney (sorry if I spelt it wrong) was amazing with helping me out. I had a huge order and she made sure everything was correct and made to our liking! I want to say thank you so much for your kindness and patience with me! I can only say great things about Bagel Chalet! Everything is alway so fresh and tasty, the breakfast sandwiches are like biting into heaven. No.Joke. We order every Friday and you guys always satisfy in every way! Love you guys! You definitely want to eat here!!!!

Did they hire all new employees during the week? They can’t even slice the bagels in half when you order butter or cream cheese on it?I ordered two eggs and cheese on a roll. I receive barely a scrambled egg and one slice of cheese.This is rediculous, the quality has gone down. It’s a shame when you give so much business to them.

This is one of the busiest bagel places that I know of. If you are going during peak hours, it will be packed! The food is really good but my one complaint is the salad size. The large size is more like a medium or a big small. This is kind of disappointing since a salad with grilled chicken is around 15$. I highly recommend their shrimp salad on a pumpernickel bagel!

Food is great but....... place was packed had to be over 30 people in this tiny place plus a lady with no mask was repeatedly coughing into her hands then standing by the cold drinks she kept touching and picking the kid drinks that had mickey and mini mouse on the top for like 5 mins while still coughing into her hands. No one said anything, eventually she asked how much was the drink and they answered her by name so i guess shes a usual customer. Im not trying to cause trouble but she made me feel sick in the stomach they way she was hacking away and standing next to a bunch of young kids who also didnt have mask, we are never going to get over covid this way.

This is typically my go-to bagel spot but I’ve had a few rough experiences the last couple of times. The food is always good, however, I’ve been charged the wrong price a few times and now check my receipt closely. My wife went in to get lunch recently and waited about 40min. She said people were getting food before her and no one would acknowledge her. I know this place gets busy but my wife had such a bad experience that she said she will never go there again.

Bagel Chalet makes the best bagels! Every time I’m in the area visiting family, I will stop there every morning for breakfast. The staff is wonderful too!

Manager is not respectful person. He told me all driver has to use back door . I said ok can I pick up my food next time I can come back door . he said no go out and use back door . He has some problems with Muslim people. I will never go there again .

I literally got an egg and cheese sandwich with salt and pepper. Tell me why when I took a bite there was no cheese, salt or pepper and just a egg. I even got charged for all the stuff I didn’t even get on the sandwich.

Great breakfast but be ready for time you might spend to get your order cuz they are just busy

The salads are excellent! You can get anything they have on it and so much is included in the price.

Wow what a bagel place, will become my new go toBagels are great but you can find that on long Island at a lot of placesIts the sheer number of choices you have, cream cheese so many, and they are all really goodService was fast for so many people on line, but there are so many people working it goes fastPleanty of drinks , coffee and teaIt was a really clean nice placeIn be back many times

I deliver for them daily and have eaten here many times. Quality assured! Can be busy but thats given for any great restaurant! 10/10

I continue to try to give this place a chance, but my order is wrong every time and the portions are extremely cheap. The amount I pay for an egg sandwich compared to the mess I receive is outrageous.

The customer service was beyond what I expected!! The food is fresh and wonderful and it feels like the employees enjoy working there.Will be back!!!

THE CUSTOMER IS ALWAYS...WRONG??? I went there with my boyfriend who wanted a bagel w lox spread. i am low-carb so i was considering a wrap or salad but there were all either 8.99 or 9.99 except for ONE that said 5.99. I picked up the salad waiting forEVER for the bagel, only to be told that THEY HAD MARKED THE SALAD WRONG and i still had to pay 9.99! so when they rang up my boyfriends bagel it came to exactly $4.00-- the amount they fought with me over, and we just walked out so they could lose the $4.00 anyway. At least the manager was nice enough to remind me that I wasnt in a supermarket!!!! HA NO my friend, youre a small business that just lost 2 customers and hopefully more after reading my post!!!!!

They are always so friendly and professional. When I start my morning deliveries I always drive here first because I know Ill be able to have a great start to my day. On some days I even get offered a fresh bagel if another customer from a delivery service ends up canceling an order. Its always a nice pleasant surprise :).. check out the pictures of some of the delicious bagels Ive tried here !

Delicious bagels ☺️ Great price. Nice place to sit down .

Lovely busy little deli/bagel shop I love this place they have a lot of people friendly people on staff to help keep things moving quickly it didnt take long at all they even will bring you your meal to the nice tables that they have big glass window so you can watch people going by or coming in and out hot coffee they got everything thats a full-service Deli as well I highly recommend this place!!

The best bagels and cream cheese in NY 💜

I loved this place before I looked at my recipe to find they charged too much for a piece of lettuce on sandwich. The people work too hard I feel sorry for them

Get a lot of Doordash orders from here and food for myself. Their sandwiches are the bomb. 😋

I ordered a chopped salad with romaine, carrots, black olives and cucumber. When I got it there was bacon in it. I do not eat meat. This is careless and unacceptable. Do better!

I love this place. Food is top notch. A little cluttered in walking space but, once you have their food, you will forget all about it.

The food is very good I just had to stand online a little longer than I thought

O me gusta pq la attention s spectacular o is because the attention is spectacular

Always great food. Best bagels on long island

This store, for the 2nd time screwed up the simplest order. Grilled cheese with tomato salt and pepper. So simple. And for the 2nd time I get to work and open up to 2 slices of cold American and a slice of tomato between 2 slices of uncooked bread. I will still come here, it seems to be only the Latin employees that screw this up. I dont think they even know what grilled cheese is!!!! Unreal

The tall waiter at the counter is bad service.

I have been a Bagel Chalet, COMMACK NY customer for over 30 years (both owners.) I support local business and have enjoyed Bagel Chalet’s service and food for a very long time. But I need to share what happened to me last week so you can make safe choices for yourself during and after this pandemic.I am a 66-year-old woman and was on the line social distancing last week and wearing my mask.The area can be tight while waiting in line, but everyone ahead of me was keeping their distance.As I was waiting, a group of young people got in line behind me. One of the couples (clearly under the influence of a substance) were being very inappropriate and kept bumping into me. I moved ahead a little, and they moved as well; I realized what was happening, so I asked if they could keep their distance and showed them the markers on the floor to indicate where everyone should be standing. In the loudest tone, the guy looked at me, then called me a vulgar word several times, and then took off his mask and coughed directly on me. The store went silent. All of the counter clerks stopped and watched, including the owner Nick. I stood up for myself and told him to quit it and back up.He proceeded to repeat the vulgar words without a mask. A male customer stepped in and told him to stop that language and be respectful while another male customer went up to Nick to tell him what was going on, but Nick watched the whole scene and did absolutely nothing. He never told the young man to put his mask back on; he didn’t tell him to calm down or make him leave the premises. He just stood behind the front counter in full view and did nothing to protect his customers.After I placed my order, I walked to the counter to pay, Nick just looked at me and never said a word...no sorry, no I will speak to this fool once he sits down; he did not even ask if I was okay after being verbally assaulted at his establishment while he watched.So after 30 years of frequenting this establishment, the Bagel Chalet and I will part ways...Nick and his staff should be ashamed of themselves for not supporting a customer that has walked through those doors multiple times a week for three decades. The almighty dollar was too much for Nick to think clearly and do the right thing!Be safe out there...

Top 3 best BEC on long Island hands down. Friendly staff, friendly atmosphere and lots of choices! Cant go wrong

This place is the absolute WORST. Never a time where my order wasn’t messed up. They refuse to toast my bagel when I ask repeatedly - who likes cold bagels?? Why is a hash brown an option if you’re not going to include it every time I ask for one? The bacon is beyond burnt. If anyone’s interested in eating a decent bagel go to First Class Bagels in Deer Park

Very good. Come here all the time

We love Bagel Chalet! A friend raved about their great chopped salads, so we decided to try them a few months ago and werent disappointed. It was definitely worth the 20 minute ride (hard to find a chopped salad on the south shore), and bonus: you get a choice of a free bagel or bag of bagel chips! And the owner is the best... so friendly and accommodating! Weve been back a bunch of times and will continue to do so!

Love there diet bagels.

Food is good, but they have messed up my order a few times. The horrendous fried oil smell keeps me away from going.

Tried this place for the first time today. Ordered the jalapeño cream cheese and my god it was amazing!!

So gross! The bacon is burnt the avocado is brown. My husband says his was burnt on his sandwhich as well.. You pay a premium for the worst food. One time they forgot my bacon we realized when home and they refused to refund my card. Really annoying. I get gluten free bagels due to celiac disease and everytime they have some other cross contaminated topping on it. They taste terrible too. Wont be back.

The place is always busy but the line goes fast. The food is always fresh and the bagels are delicious.

Best selection of breakfast and other foods. Service is always excellent, helpful staff and quick orders even when the line is long. Been going there for years and it never disappoints

Yummy

One of my favorite bagel spots on LI! Everything is super fresh and always delicious!

Best bagels on LI 🥯

Not quite as good as Brooklyn Bagel in Queens, but almost as good and more reasonably priced.

Very good egg sandwiches. Omelette station.Fresh salad bar. Tuna salad, chicken salad, lowfat egg white spinach salad, & low fat honey mustard chicken salad.Large assortment of coffee, tea & juices.Plenty of seating. Fast, friendly service.The restaurant is clean.The line on a Sunday morning is long but it moves quickly! :)

Good food, but extremely overpriced. paid 9.50 for a bacon egg and cheese with hash brown. never have had to pay over $5 for a bacon egg and cheese with hash brown. i don’t recommend it. 75 cents for just lettuce and $8 for turkey on a sandwich. absolutely insane. i don’t recommend buying unless you are loaded or just do not care at all.

I’d give this place zero stars if possible.

Best bagels by far in Long Island.

Love this place for several years now. Extremely delicious & fresh food. Excellent coffee. Courteous, efficient & kind staff.A true gem in the heart of Commack.😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀😀

Great NY bagel - best in town. Excellent wraps and salads too

Ive loved their bagels since I was in high school. I used to come here for lunch during my lunch period at Commack HS. So every time I come back, its like a trip back in time. The bagels have always been great. The cream cheese is great. The only difference between then and now....is, im old enough to be a parent to the staff. Theyre wonderful and polite. Just as theyve always been.

I was told this was one of the best places in Long island to get bagels. I was not disappointed! I came from a world of lenders bagels and there is a day and night difference between the two. Bagel chalet is my go-to bagel place whenever Im in Long island! Highly recommend it!

Quality quality food. They always make sure that you have everything you ordered and are always on beat. Generally a really busy spot, so the wait is a little longer than other places, but definitely worth it. 1000% recommend

I ordered a plain bagel and it had so many seeds in it it was ridiculous, it was to the point that it wasnt even plain anymore! I asked for a refund and was denied, this place is dirty.

I love Bagel Chalet. I came here all my life and was out of state for the past couple years and when i came back this was one of the first places I was craving! I love the egg everything bagels, the cream cheese is so good, also the bacon egg and cheese on a roll is delicious. One of the best places around. Chopped salads and sandwiches are also amazing. Ive eaten here over 100 times and never had a bad meal. No lies!

Best bagle on long island

These guys make some pretty good bagels. As a non-New Yorker, I may not be the most qualified reviewer but when I get a bagel from here and eat it the same day, the taste difference is huge! They also have a great selection of sandwich and salad options. Occasionally, the line and the wait can get long though and appear a little chaotic.

Very good and nicely portioned sandwiches

Egg sandwich was skimpy at best. Waited too long for it. No juice either 🤧

Took very long to get our order, in fact it looked like they forgot all about us until we asked for our order. There was a man even standing against the wall doing nothing, so what was the issue? Customer service is terrible, they’re obviously careless here.

Fast and organized service

Best bagels around hands down. Smoked salmon always. Wouldnt go any where else but here

Owner is rude,, disrespectful and thinks he knows everything. Also horrible with his staff. Dont go here .... Horrible

Theyre not cheap with thier servings. Bagels are always on point, everything cooked the right way! Have to try thier lunch next time..

Excellent establishment 10 of 10

Bagels are good and so is the coffee. My only problem is waiting on line for at least 10-15 minutes every time I go there.

A great deli with a nice selection for breakfast, and lunch, highly recommended!

High quality food and high prices

Awesome the owner nick is all about old school costumer service !!!

Great tasting bagels

The most amazing bacon, egg and cheese on a buttered everything bagel I ever had in my life! Yesss. This place has been here since I was a kid. Always loved it. People literally line up on the weekends to get some of the goodness they serve

They take too long to do the orders very bad

I have been going to bagel chalet for years, but the food gets worse in quality, and heftier in price. Not worth the visit

Friendly staff, nicely decorated. The bagels and vegetable cream cheese were delicious. My new go to bagel shop.

I had many bacon egg sandwich before but jeez these are some really good bagels . One of the best I had

Bagel Chalet is the best bagel place in Commack. Always busy but fast accurate and pleasant service and plenty of seating.

I used to love bagel chalet. The staff was nice and food was great. Now every time I go, my order is messed up. Always. The prices are ridiculously high. $10+ for bacon egg and cheese with avocado? After paying the unbelieveable price, I got home to enjoy the sandwich and the eggs were almost completely raw and there was NO AVOCADO! I am very disappointed with the service.

Place very clean food is good servers v r7 polite.

Always a wait. Food is very good. A bit pricy compared to other bagel stores around the area.

Lentil soup spectacular

Same quality as always

Bagels were awesome. Service was very good. Selection was great. A perfect morning stop. Just go there. Parking was free and easy.

I’ve been going there forever and today I ordered a turkey BLT and was finish up my sandwich until I found a dead smashed fly in my sandwich absolutely disgusting fkn place is lucky I didn’t call them up. I don’t recommend may look nice and clean but it disgusting.

Amazing place featuring a great staff and great food.

Foods good. Just check your order they seem to forget stuff.

Nice people. Quick service.

Always delicious!

Great service and amazing people we always go here

Excellent food, excellent service, bright and happy energy!I absolutely loved visiting and eating here. Hot coffee and a delish bagel with lox!

Good low carb bagels

Best bagels on long islandBeen their customer for over 20 years. Bagels are excellent and I have shipped them to friends and family across USA. Occasionally we will slice and freeze excess bagels at home and after reheating, they taste same as fresh. Nick is running a great operation. Thank you.

Very good food service people r very nice

I have always loved this place. Every time we visit long Island, we come here for the best bagels in town. I loved the rainbow bagel for my daughter as well. Vsnt wait to come back!!

Hands down, best bagels around. Long lines always assure you of the freshest food. I love their oatmeal too!

Best bagels on long Island. This place is almost always busy, but the line moves and the staff is excellent. They have a great selection of breakfast and lunch options. Everything I have tried here has been excellent. Highly recommend their French toast. Only downside is they are a little pricey compared to other bagel shops. But, you do get what you pay for so it is not a knock against them.