I don’t normally post reviews, but this pizza really left an impression on me…a bad one. This was honestly one of the worst pizzas that I’ve ever had. Cheap, crackery crust. It really feels like a cheap frozen pizza. I’d rather save my money and get a Little Caesars hot and ready. Save your money and go to one of Buffalo’s many great pizza places.

If youre looking for NY style pizza, this isnt it. If youre looking for Buffalo style pizza, this isnt it. If youre looking for cheap pizza thats palatable then youve found your spot. Had the boneless wings and they were soaked in grease. With so many other solid pizza places in the area, Im not sure how this place is still in business. Do yourself a favor and dont even bother trying it no matter how appealing their prices/deals seem.

Ordered for the first time. Pizza is cheap like 7/11 or Little Cease but cost the same as high end restaurants. They didnt follow my order instructions either.

Best wings Ive had in a while!Really love pizza guys restaurant. Wings are great and pizza is even better! Good selection, so picky eaters have a lot to choose from.

Very good flavor halal pizza . I ordered kebab pizza it was delicious. Thank you pizza guysI will back again.

Im not sure why this has so many glowing reviews... They completely screwed-up our order, and it was like cheap frozen pizza! The sauce and the cheese were leaking off and I will not be returning.

Asked for light sauce and banana peppers.. got neither.. kinda seems like a frozen pizza? Probably better off with a 5 dollar equivalent

I order from these guys at least weekly, Ive tried all the other delivery places that come to my house and they are by far the best. Food is always on time, correct, warm, and delivery people are always friendly. The one time they forgot a small item they drove back to deliver it, vs. just taking it off the bill which was awesome. Highly recommend.

Would not recommend to anyone. Worst pizza ever! The crust reminded me of cheap frozen pizza. I had better pizza in high school back in the 80s. I have actually had better frozen pizza. I personally will never be ordering from here again

I came here to leave an amazing review from all my experiences getting food from here, and out of curiosity I started scrolling through all the other comments left for them. Sadly, I am quite surprised that some people compared this pizza to frozen pizza because I did not think that at all. I had this pizza once at a friends gathering and ever since then whenever my Fiancé and I feel like it or have guests over we order from here cuz we’re hooked (so almost every weekend)!! Their prices are also very reasonable, and they provide such excellent customer service! So many times they have gone out of their way for us, we don’t live in their delivery area but out of great customer service they deliver to us all the way in Cheektowaga!! I definitely recommend this Pizza place.

Ordered via Slice for the first time. 63.00, nothing was delivered. Called restaurant, no answer. Slice support 40 minutes ago said would be delivered momentarily. Slice App is trash. Restaurant unreliable

Great food, amazing service, you will not be disappointed! Loved the inside of the restaurant as well. Gives a nice cozy feeling. Highly recommended!

Good priced food and garlic knots are very tasty.Definitely will be eating here again!

I am not sure why there are so many glowing reviews, if Im being truly honest. The first time I ordered from Pizza Guys I thought the crust seemed like a mid-range quality pre-made crust from the grocery store. It may be that their overall type of pizza is just not my cup of tea -- its not really WNY style, so its likely not a fair comparison. Their wings were pretty decent although they were small. Their steak sub was apparently pretty good but I threw away the turkey sub -- it was not palatable. I wish I could say that this was only a bad night, but I accidentally ordered a second time and was not impressed. Your mileage may vary.

My boyfriend recently started doordashing, the smell of the car is what got us! We ordered from here 2 days later and have been hooked ever since. Homemade meatballs! Bruchetta bread is on point! Not only that, chicken finger sub and boneless wings were perfect! Definitely is a new favorite for an awesome price! Pizza and garlic knots were killer as well!! Yum!

Great Pizza!!! Fast delivery and amazing taste. 👏 well done Pizza Guys!!!Highly recommend

Pros: Great pizza place with halal options ( inluding salam, chicken). Taste is great, thin pizza, also has halal chicken wings. I tried, primevera, chicken pizza, sweet potato fries and wings.Cons: Little away from city center ( in Lancaster). Not a lot of pizza sauces. I did not like mango sauce over fries, but my wife did.

Ordered a Meat Lovers and Wings, cooking was on point. Great quality pizza, Would order here again.

I had their pizza and it was excellent! Their overall menu has many options, cant wait to try some of them!

We are on the way to Niagara Falls and searched for good pizza and we found one pizza guys. We ordered food and it was very delicious and their service was very friendly and the price was reasonable.

Absolutely delicious! and the pasta sizes are large. You get more than what you pay for. The sauce is amazing as well as the staff. Very clean too!Like

We just ordered a pizza and two subs from this place. Hair in not only one but two of the subs. This is all on top of the guy who delivered my contactless pizza had a clear glove on with blood on his finger. I really wanted to try and support this place but just can’t do it. These folks could have cared less that this happened and actually called us back and said “Did you just call, oh okay would you like to order food”. Some folks just don’t know what they are doing or how to manage restaurants.

New Pizza Guys is widely chosen for delicious food with absolute great experience ! We had Buffalo chicken yummy hot pizza - round pie topped with buffalo Chicken, where you get more than what you pay for a selection.Very clean, delicious food and excellent service quality.I must visit whenever get a chance.

Ordered cheese pizza. Really well, fresh baked. Great customer service.

Truly a gem! The food is delicious and clean and fresh. The service is outstanding. Thank you

Im not sure if I came here on a bad day but I ordered 2 slices of their cheese & pepperoni pizza and honestly, it looked & tasted exactly like a frozen pizza from Wegmans, and not a good one. I really wanted to like it because theyre very close to me but it was horrible & not cheap.

Excellent food and service quality. the delicious taste still lingers on the tip of my tongue. an absolute great experience :D

I ordered a turkey sub. The turkey was so thick and processed. It looked more like a prepackaged and widely distributed turkey that you would buy from save a lot. The meat to veggie ratio was off as well. I will say i liked the bread. Cant say the service was terrible the order arrived in a timely fashion. However it is clear to me that they dont buy quality ingredients. Prioritizing cheap ingredients over making a quality sub is not something that will keep you above the competition here in an area where there are dozens more pizza places to choose from.

Very good pizza. perfect cook . very happy because it was HALAL. will try again

These are by far the best calzones Ive ever had. The portions are huge, my kids absolutely love these calzones. I have also ordered quite a few other things from them and I must say the garlic knots are a must try as well as a bruschetta bread. The staff is super friendly and accommodating as well. Highly recommend a must try!

First time eating their food. It was amazing, definitely order again. Thanks

Very happy with the slice I tried! I stopped to get gas and a coffee and I seen a sigh that said $2 slices, I’m not big on trying new pizza but this definitely made me feel like I was in my old neighborhood!! Awesome taste!I will definitely be here again.

If you looking for Halal pizza , Pizza Guys is the Best , I ordered white pizza it was with ricotta . wow ...Best pizza ..... love it....

The customer service & the pizza was top notch!

Odrerd Chicken Cutlet pizza. Best chicken pizza I ever eat. Very nice place. Its far form my home but I will be there again.

Ordered thru door dash. Dreadfully hungry, we ordered the trio pasta with alfredo sauce a milkshake some fries and a sausage calzone.The alfredo sause tasted worse than canned sauce as well as the pasta. The calzone was good as well as the milkshake. The fries were not our favorite but were edible.

THIS FOOD IS FANTASTIC!!!! Very authentic Italian. Absolutely delicious and the portion sizes are large. You get more than what you pay for. The sauce is amazing as well as the staff. Very clean too!

Ordered stuffed shells and garlic knots with a slice of cheesecake. Stuffed shells were amazing as were the garlic knots. The cheesecake however was thrown carelessly into a box, and was clearly frozen. Not impressed

I can without a doubt tell you this is worse than gas station pizza. We decided to try this place as the previous pizza place (Perfetto’s) was absolutely horrible. We got a large pizza and all I can say is there is ZERO flavor. The sauce is bland and the dough is terrible. The people were very nice in the store but I feel obligated to write this review as it was so bad and people should be aware of the flavorless pizza this place is pushing on Lancaster.

This is a best meat and vegetable pizza I ever had.

Ordered threw uber eats ordered a red pepper and artichoke pizza and medium boneless wings with garlic parm French fries packed to perfection deliciousness

Lamb Kebab pizza is great good pricing too!

Awesome pizza. Was very quick. If u like small crust on your pizza u will like this place. Alot of flavor. Just very good all around

I heard a rumor it was under new ownership, hopefully they change their advertising strategy because food made by my dogs could quite possibly be the worst marketing idea ever. I get it, people like dogs. The owners of this place obviously love their dogs. But the thought of having someone elses pets and my order of food, together, even if only in jest, is one of the most unappetizing marketing campaigns Ive ever heard of.Hi, yes Id like to order a large pizza with pepperoni and dog hair...

I have come to pizza guys when it was with the previous owner perfecto and now with the new owners pizza guys. I liked both, however the new owners for pizza guys have done an even more improvement. With the quality of the food. The taste is even better and the quality is very satisfactory. much more of a selection as well. The menu contains a ton of stuff. really liked the subs and the wings also. I order from pizza guys alot more now

Only place around Depew or Lancaster that understands what a crispy chicken wing should taste like! Food is amazing great bang for your buck.

Great place.Perfect taste.Loved it. ❤️

Extremely delicious. Might just say my FAVORITE :)

Won a $50 gift certificate at a cancer benefit for this place and they refused to honor it. Ordered 60 bucks of food for a party and they just said no for no reason. Was not expired. Bad business. Lost repeat customer for life

Took too long to make my food so I wouldnt be able to receive it because I had to work and now they wont give me a refund

Best pizza . I HAD SHEET PIZZA AND 50 WINGS FOR $ 52.99. ITS BEST DEAL IN NEW YORK .

I just loved the extra cheese pizza.

The pasta is soooo good

Pizza was very good . try one slice ... it was very good

“New Name” “New Ownership” same god awful food. They’ll get squashed quickly when Leo’s opens. Save your $$

Not good. This is based on the pizza. It was a greasey mess. Thin crust that given the amount of grease doesnt hold up well. Also almost no sauce..... given this was the first time I have eaten there so it could have been an off day. I have heard the wings are good, but is it is Pizza your after keep going down the road there are 2 much better places... ALSO I HAVE NO RESPECT FOR A RESTAURANT THAT HAS FAMILY AND FRIENDS WRITE FAKE REVIEWS TO HELP OUT YOUR RATING AND DEFRAUD THE PUBLIC. if you want better ratings make better food.

Excellent food, fantastic value and outstanding people here!We come all the way from Hamburg for the food- yes its that good! We have become regulars on the Italian dinners. Not only is it good its also a tremendous value. Everything we have tried from Perfetto we have enjoyed. I can personally recommend the lasagna, chicken parmesan, fettuccine alfredo and authentic antipasto salad. Besides the quality food the people are very friendly and accommodating. Give them a try- youll be glad you did!

Finally... a place to get good food at reasonable prices here in Lancaster, NY!Their pizza, subs, dinners, wings are all fantastic! Their pizzas have just the right ratio of sauce and cheese with an excellent pizza crust. Their Mon - Tue Special of $10.00 Lg 1 topping pizza is a great deal and I love their chicken parm, dinner, which is on special ever Tuesday for only $7.95. Wed they have $2.00 off all subs! And so much more.Im thankful that we have Perfetto right here in the heart of Lancaster, NY!

The food is awesome the eggplant parmesan is #1 in my book so is the white pizza keep up the good work

Excellent service....pizza and wings are awesome!!

Staff was nice. Roast beef sub was disgusting. I threw it out. Ham sub was ok.I would not try again

Very yummy buffalo chicken pizza

I work next door and get lunch here so good and huge servings

This is the best pizza in town

New to the this area and have used Perfettos twice for parties. Everyone loves the pizza and their wings are amazing!

Pizza sauce was incredibly sweet. Sweetiest sauce Ive ever had. Very surprised that there is no mention of this anywhere! Probably a good pie if thats your thing, but i dont care for sugar with my pepperoni. I dont know. Maybe it was a mistake? I may go back but not for pizza

Great bang for your buck, love the homemade quality of the sauce and food..really great for Lancaster!

Ordered a pizza, brought it home and had one bite. Now putting it in the oven because it is not cooked through. $25 for a pizza I shouldnt have to cook it too.

The food was good.

Get the Zilla Pizza, OMFG SO GOOD!

Great food and wonderful staff

Best food in town order from here all the time

Delicious food!!!

I love the roast beef subs. The pizza is great too!!!

Best pizza in buffalo

Terrible ☹️ waited over 1/2 hour from the time they said my order would be ready for cold pasta that had no flavor.

The people are amazing and the food was phenomenal

Great food.Hate to see it change hands.

Another new pizza place in Lancaster. I enjoyed this pizza, it was like a thinner crust Buffalo style. l prefer thinner crust pizzas and it had just the right amount of sauce and cheese. Out of the couple south Lancaster pizza places I would rank this # 2 behind Picassos for their pizza.I also had 10 hot wings and 10 Chiavetta wings. The Chiavetta wings were a disappointment I was hoping for them to be grilled but they had no grill marks. They were too soft, not crispy like they were just tossed in Chiavettas sauce would not get again. Ideally they would be marinated and grilled with the Chiavettas sauce. The hot wings were fine but I would order them extra crispy next time I order wings from Perfetto.Overall a nice new edition to the already crowded Lancaster pizza market. I will go back and get their pizza or try one of their pasta dinners.

About Breaded wings.? Just say wow!

Good food close to home

Very delicious food

The worst food ever !! I ordered a slice of pizza & a steak quesadilla . The delivery person was late and complaining how busy he was . After the food arrived I opened up the pizza and saw a dried out slice that had looked like it was sitting around since yesterday . I opened the steak quesadilla and found it obviously cold . But the steak was a steak um !!! I swear it was only one steak um for the whole order . It contained mostly cheese and the dough . They also forgot the sour cream . $20 for nothing . Never again !

Awesome stinger sub today. Lots of meat.

Testy pizza n chicken wings is awesome...

Best food in town and the people are awesome

Best pizza place

Best pizza around Lancaster with out a doubt

Awesome food

FIREEEEEEEEEEE and you get a lot for what you pay. Hope they stick around!

Perfect every time!!!

N.Y.C. Real pizza.

Yuck

Love it