Drove up with a bad tire, placed an order, 5 days later I called the tire store to follow up because I had not heard from them and they never ordered the tire. Receptionist suggested I drive to Riverhead (my tire is flat and my car is not drivable) instead of just ordering a tire for me. I guess they dont like to follow through on orders. Went back to my local mechanic and he has no problem ordering the tire, and my car will be fixed pronto. My mistake for going to a tire store.

Went to them for an alignment and to reset my steering wheel after having front end work done barely rest the steering wheel and didnt do the alignment, new tires on the front are now worn bad on one side

Good work done quickly. Reasonable prices.

I paid a little over $1k this summer for new rotors and brake pads. Also had an issue with shaking steering wheel. The shaking issue was no better when I got the car back, and I brought it to another shop. Turns out these guys changed 2 rear rotors and did NOT change the brake pads...slimy characters at Consumers!

Great place to take care of or buy tires. Fair prices, good service and friendly people. Usually just a short wait. What more can you ask for?

Great service! Everyone was very courteous and they quickly helped us with an emergency repair. Thank you!

I am a returning customer. I had a appointment at 2 PM on Tuesday I called up at 11:30 am and they said I can come in early. They installed four new tires on my jeep. I’m very happy with the service and the price I paid. Definitely would recommend consumer tire to anybody looking for a fair price and friendly people and fast work.

Excellent experience.I had tire issues. 💀Professional, friendly, fast and honest.I would return in a heart beat.

Super fast, easy, honest service with food prices. Honestly this is one of my first auto experiences on the east end where I didn’t feel taken advantage of.

I called to ask if the gentlemen could balance wheels on my car, he asked me to leave the car there and he would do it during the day, i explained that i am on holiday and would like an appointment during the week if possible since we have only one car. He basically said Arrrgg and hanged up, So imagine the type of person you deal with at this location.

I came in at 8AM without an appointment, with a slow air leak in a run-flat tire, and I was greeted pleasantly. Tire was repaired within 15 minutes and I was on my way. I cant imagine any better service. Friendly and competent staff.

Stay away from this business if you know about cars. Ive had multiple shady mishaps from this place and dont even think about asking to bring your own parts! Terrible business owner. Lacking in people skills. It would be amazing to have a knowledgeable and trustworthy mechanic or tireshop replace the current owners. Such a convenient space for a tireshop but lacks in the quality of business.

THESE GUYS ARE THE BEST IN THE AREA. WHEN I HAVE TROUBLE I DO NOT GO ANY WHERE ELSE. EXCELLENT ALL AROUND!

Mike is great. They have taken care of my tires and oil over my last three vehicles as well as many of our work trucks and vans..Always gives you his best advice and if they cant help he will make sure you know where to go to get you back on the road as soon as possible.

Clear example of people that want to take advantage of your need. They are willing to charge you for letting you walk in

Treated terrible and overcharged for simple work,wouldn’t recommend them to anyone

We are so very fortunate to have Mikes Consumers Tire shop here in East Hampton village. Always great, friendly advice and excellent service.

Mike is a lovely man and gave me good advice over the phone. I thought Id need a new tire because of a nail puncture, but he said that can easily be repaired rather than trying to sell me a new set of tires.

Great service. Great price. Always fair!

The conversation goes as follows: me: lId like to get the brakes changed on my 2015 Subaru Sti, I work next door, and already have the parts because I ordered them onlineOwner: well youll be looking for someone else to put them in then. If your smart enough to buy the parts your smart enough to put them inStrongly suggest staying away from this shop, he clearly only cares about making money and not his customers. Could have made a lot off of the labor, but instead decided to be rude and dismissive. Not how a business owner should act.

Very professional family owned businessRare particularly in the Hamptons to find ethical people that do what they promiseIf you need any auto related help, this is the place to go

Always great service. Always fair price too.

Fast reliable service. Nice people too.

Nice guys...fair price...highly recommend

Good service and really nice people work there 👍👍👍👍

Great, quick service. No attitude.

Great place, honest people

Good service!

Overpriced