What a wonderful place! This store is absolutely packed with puzzles for all ages and interests. And the owner is so helpful. When looking for lower count puzzles for adults (meaning 200 piece puzzles that arent just cartoon characters), she had lots of wonderful options. And there were some great challenging puzzles as well. This is a fun stop for kids and adults.

First time going here. A little hard to findSign says TOY and is Not very big. Hangs outside by the door. Store is delightful. Lots of puzzles and learning type toys. Owner was very very nice and helpful. No trouble returning a n unopened puzzle from Christmas without a receipt for in store credit. We will shop there again. A little pricey but worth it to support locally owned small business. They have items you dont see elsewhere.

They are THE BEST!!! The toy selection is great, especially their selection of Green Toys. I love that I can just throw them in the dishwasher and their made from 100% recycled plastic here in the USA. They make great kids birthday gifts!

The sweetest little store! I’ve bought Christmas gifts there for 3 years now and they always have such high quality products and friendly service. Highly recommend!

Fantastic toy shop. If they dont have they will try to find. I love the green toys and the playmobil sets for my son. They are his favorite toys.

The Cedarburg Toy Co. truly is a treasure, I always find unique gifts here!!One of my favorite go to stores in downtown Cedarburg!Great friendly and helpful staff and owners!!!

Terrible customer service. Wanted to shop for my 6 grandchildren today at the Toy store, but was told to leave for not wearing a mask dispite the fact that I meet several of the Governors exemption rules. I understand, private store their rules, but the clerk was so incredibly rude about it! Lost a huge dollar sale today and in the future. I will never go back.

Outstanding place! Perfect location in downtown Cedarburg. The owners are kind, joyful, and engaging. Theyre the perfect couple to own a toy store. My fiance and I had good conversation and were treated so well! They have a really unique and fun selection of American-made toys. The multi-lingual wooden blocks intrigued us, and the thinking putty was great! We loved it so much we went back for more. We cant wait to go back and take others.

So cute and homey feeling. The staff is super nice and very helpful. There are a lot of cool toys you might not find elsewhere. I wish they had a bigger store!

Extremely helpful. Greeted all who entered/exited. Seemed genuinely interested in all customers from two to 102 in age. Somewhat pricey but for the individualized problem solving well worth it!

Loads of fun and educational toys that you wont find at any other store in the area. The owners and staff are beyond friendly and helpful. Always great to support an awesome local business. Highly recommended.

Natasha is very nice and friendly. The store itself is awesome... Id highly recommend it. Great experience!

Cedarburg Toy Company rocks! The owners/staff are super friendly and helpful, the store features/sells only American-made toys, and prices are very reasonable. The displays are charming.

If I were to suggest a toy store, I would have to say this is the one and a to mention! The owner was so helpful and let me look around, yet was always there when I needed her! She knew me so well, that she helped me pick out toys for me niece and nephews visit, by helping me when I needed it without me even having to ask her! I would give this six stars if it were possible!

Natasha and Zac are such wonderful store owners. They and their staff ALWAYS are so kind to everyone who walks in the door. A lovely range of toys, books and gadgets and they are constantly updating their stock with new and fun made in the USA products. Please support this store and these wonderful people!

Everything in the store is made in the US! Prices are very reasonable, and the service is unparalleled - theyll even wrap your gifts behind the counter so your kid cant see them! A truly magical toy store in picturesque, historic downtown Cedarburg.

I interviewed the owner and wow I am impressed. She is the nicest person I every met. Come and by some of her toys at the company and have the time of your life at the toy company.5 million cheers for Natasha-Nadia

A variety of fun STEM and creative thinking toys.

The store sells American made products, I love that!The owners are so helpful and knowledgeable. My kids love going to play a bit and find birthday presents for their friends.

Great little toy shop! All made in USA toys, excellent service. Kids love it here!

Toy selection is good, but the staff is what shines here. They go above and beyond

Amazing customer service. They see you once and remember you. All products are made in the USA. I cant say no to my kids in this store because I love supporting this local spot!

Outstanding service!

Great family owned company. Treats everyone like family.

Cool store with local toys! Pretty well priced!

Cute, trendy and new vintage toys sold here.

American made toys!! Clever interesting fun! Love it!!

Interesting and fun toys for all ages!

I cant say enough good things about Cedarburg Toy Co. I purchase gift certificates for my grandsons and Natashia is alway very kind and helpful. Needless to say this is a five star establishment!

Lots of fun stuff, all made in america

Very nice owner who is always cheerful and trying to help.

Very helpful staff, loads of cool stuff

Great place!

Very friendly!