W O W. Even if you only walk in and smell the fresh baked cookies, its worth going. The ice cream is so good. The homemade waffle cones are tasty. Very cute place. Lots of room to sit outside in the back.

Wow, so Guilford ice cream is pretty good. Cant say Ive had it before. So solid on that. But the cookie. One of, if not, the best cookies Ive ever had. Peanut butter cookie with Reeces peanut butter cups mashed into it. Next July my birthday cake is coming from this place.

Wonderfully relaxed ambiance with amazing ice cream combinations. The cookies are so soft and huge. So many different options to choose from. I need to go back

I ordered a salted caramel, chocolate chip, m&m, and macadamia nut cookie. They were fairly large as they should be for $3.50 a piece. Wasnt impressed with the texture, too hard and dry, Especially around the edges. The caramel cookie was the best and softest of them all and had a very nice rich buttery flavor.. really delicious..although the edges were still too dry and hard.. I had to microwave them to soften them up. All of the cookies were decent tasting, they would be much better if they were more soft and chewy though.

Amazing place with delicious (and filling!) ice cream and cookie combinations. The workers are also super friendly and helpful.

Cute place. Tasty cookies and ice cream!

Super great place for ice cream, but their cookies are to die for! They are always well staffed so you never have to wait long. The inside of the establishment is adorable! I absolutely love the neon lights. The back area theyve made is so nice for eating outside! Love this place

I got a milkshake! Omg it was so good! There was plenty of seating inside and outside

Cute little ice cream shop with a variety of sweet treats to choose from. I didnt give 5 stars because they were out of alot of flavors on the evening ( Sunday) we were there.

Best ice cream shop in Buffalo! Huge portions. Enough to share. Try an ice cream sandwich. One of a kind!

Excellent custard. Very clean place. Nice atmosphere. Several places to relax and enjoy your ice cream.

Such a cute little retro style sweet shop! Theres also a backyard area as well, and I cant wait to come here with my friends. Such a calming atmosphere with tons of awesome choices.

What a gem!! This place is adorable and delicious. Such an incredible combo of homemade ice cream and cookies. And the ice cream cookie sandwiches are HUGE!! If you love ice cream...and cookies (who doesnt??!!)...then visit this nostalgic establishment immediately. 5 stars!!

Such a great creamy and rich ice cream!!!Very cute on the inside with great details.Side walkway has windows to use later - and great back deck and enclosed grass patio out back to enjoy your ice creamAnd they now have pup cups!

As far as ice cream shops go this place is above average. Awesome back yard sitting area. Bring your dog, needs to be leashed of course.

Its a clean place and the two young ladies where Very nice. I enjoy the ice cream and the homemade cookies was delicious. Ill be back

I had a 77, which is like a DQ Blizzard, it was AMAZING!! The staff was super nice! I will definitely go back alot more times!!

Loved it there.First time visit.From the huge assortment of homemade cookies to all kinds of Ice Cream Flavors. The decor was so perfect, busy, friendly staff.Clean, sit inside or outsideI had Blueberry Pomengrate Sorbet..Delicious..Ill be back

Excellent treats, generous servings, nice people, great value. Look forward to returning some evening to enjoy ice cream in the backyard.

The cookies and cream sundaes are fantastic and large! The outdoor seating is nice and theres a great selection of both cookies and ice cream.

First time there. Pleasant staff. Quite busy so pretty popular. Friends whove been there really liked it, so I tried it.

Ice cream sandwiches are truly monstrous in portion. Big enough to share but too good to want to. Plenty of cookie options/combos to go several times and still try something new. Back patio is a nice place to sit while you recover from your ice cream coma

The portion sizes are incredible! Plus the outside seating is a really nice set up.

Cookies and cream was a great experience very pleasant very busy and the air filled with the aroma of sweetness from the delicious cookies well worth the price. Ice cream very nicely done your way. We ate our ice cream and cookies outdoors in the yard. Very nice and pleasant back there made very good use of every inch of the yard. Well done Cookies and Cream 🍨🍦. ! May your business be Blessed .

Cute little spot! Awesome cookies. Everything is made fresh and warm when served! Huge variety of ice cream combinations. Really cool spot for the summer with a really nice outdoor patio area. Should he a fun hangout for everyone!

Always out of Cotton Candy ice cream. Im only in south buffalo on the weekends, and this is my favorite ice cream in the area. If its so popular, carry more of it. Especially on busy weekends during the summer, this is kind of rediculous. They say their unicorn flavor is similar, and its trash.

Great place ,prices are very reasonable, ice cream is delicious, wonderful staff they have too.

It was our first time since we moved into our house and we are hooked! The ice cream was delicious, the staff was super sweet and polite. Prices were very reasonable.The whole atmosphere was awesome! It was a wonderful experience and I cant wait for summer to enjoy our ice cream in the back yard area. I also cant wait to try their milkshakes and cookies as well!

Great little ice cream shop in the heart of South Buffalo with all the charm of a big location, many varieties of fresh baked cookies and ice cream cakes on hand . Also have their version of a blizzard and soft serve in vanilla chocolate 🍦 and twist . The staff was so friendly and the lines were long extending to the outside sidewalk but moved along swiftly , they offer all cards and cash pay options as well . There is also a small seating area inside and they offer uber eats pickup . I had 🥛 milkshake that was thick and rich and filled the stomach my son had a blizzard that was full of m&ms thatvwas so good . I will definitely be returning to this little gem and recommending it to everyone I know

Everyone was very nice and helpful. They made our experence very wonderful

Delicious cookies and ice cream flavors. Has soft serve too!

Ice cream delicious. Cookies awesome. Pricey !

⭐Very clean. Cookies are amazing! Huge and soft. Yum 💖 I had a small twist on a cone with a sugar cookie. My daughter had a small twist in a bowl with a salted caramel cookie. Tipped $1. Bill was $11 and some change. We had a nice time there. For sure going back 💗

Ok friends, do yourself a favor and visit Cookies & Creme if youre nearby the Buffalo area. Even if you are from the surrounding area, it is worth a drive. My husband and I were visiting from out of town, and we stopped at Cookies & Cream twice! It was that good. But be advised, you will wait - from the time we walked in to the time we were handed our order, we probably waited 20-30 minutes both times. I will still say, it is worth the wait. Literally upon walking in you smell nothing but fresh baked goods and ice cream! We visited on a Thursday and Friday evening, and there were probably 3-4 young (high school aged) people working behind the counter. I give them props for working to get everyone their order in a timely manner.This is not your typical DQ, Menchies or other chain ice cream. Their dessert items are very decadant, so it does take some time to prepare the more involved dishes. We stuck with a basic 77 as they are called - similar to a DQ Blizzard. We each ordered one, but totally could have shared. They are very generous on the ice cream servings.If youve tried their 77s, get adventurous. Their Sundaes and Cookie Sandwiches look really good too! I saw plenty while waiting for our order. Very picture worthy too - Im bummed I didnt get photos.There is indoor and outdoor seating that was clean. And both areas are cute and visually aesthetic. Cookies & Creme is very Instagram worthy!

Hands down cookies and cream has the best ice cream on Seneca I go at least once a week

Cute little ice cream/cookie shop. Great treats and friendly staff.

Cute ice cream shop, 50s style decor inside, pleasant back yard for outdoor enjoyment.

Love the ambiance and very friendly staff! Wish there were more vegan options

Wow, wow, WOW! First time here the other day and it was so hard to decide what to get with the incredible variety of goodies. My husband and I went with a couple GIANT ice cream sandwiches & a couple pints of ice cream to go. The ice cream and cookies are insanely delicious. We will definitely be back soon and will be getting one of those yummy looking ice cream cakes for my next birthday 😋

Good ice cream and cookies ...obvi ....however a sundae is your best value well worth the $8and change I got mine to go so a picture just did not happen but the cookies are huge lots flavor in the ice cream and you can split if your watching your cals

Really nice place, with really good ice cream and desserts. They always try to do something cute for kids like meet Santa around Christmas and they set up a photo shoot kind of thing in Fall. They have by far the best ice cream cakes out there, and freshly baked cookies are also on the menu, Id definitely recommend checking it out

Always a great experience love this place . Happy they are on Seneca st in south bflo

Workers had to be asked to change their gloves because they were touching their hair and digging in their ear. When working with food you should be mindful of what your doing. Not very welcoming.

Im a little late on the review lol but thia place is really cute! The inside doesnt have much too the appeal, but the backyard is beautiful!

Food, atmosphere, staff all great! Met the owner who is also very friendly. Will be back very soon. Cookies are absolutely outstanding!!!

Great selection of ice cream, big warm cookies. I had the peanut butter cup cookie.....delish!

Very unique and cute place. My ice cream sundae was delicious. 10/10 :)

Yum! Seriously up there! Chocolate peanut butter milkshake one of the best ive had ever!

The new Pumpkin Ice Cream is AMAZING 👏

This place is so nice, Check it out! The cookie sandwich is HUGE and a genius idea!

Love this place! Workers are extremely nice. Cookies are out of this world! Ice cream is yummy!

Amazing little place in South Buffalo on Seneca Street next to Sheas Seneca. I walked in and my mouth instantly watered they have all sorts of desserts every kind you could think of. The staff was extremely friendly and the cookies were bigger than the entirety of my hand as were the brownies.

We were in buffalo visiting family and were told we had to get the ice-cream sandwich. The smell of fresh cookies when you walk in is amazing. The cookie sandwich is amazing, I highly recommend.

Cookies and cream was a very enjoyable experience decor was great and the servings were huge highly recommend!!!!

What a delightful experience!!! Not only were the cookies and cream amazing, the staff and management were extremely kind and open to feedback. I grew up in the area and I love seeing the resurgence of Seneca St! We will absolutely be back. If youre reading reviews to see what to order, the waffle cone was incredible, as was the smores 77. We took some cookies home and they are amazing as well! So, I would say, order whatever your heart desires!

Such a cute little shop, cookies are rediculously soft. Ice cream is delicous. The waitresses are patent when you are new but really fast and nice !

Such a friendly and charming spot. Super delicious and creative ice cream. Will definitely recommend to anyone visiting Buffalo.

The biggest ice cream sandwich I ever seen in my life

Oh oh oh macadamia nut cookie to die for. Hsbd had #2 reeses speciality Sunday perfect for peanut butter cup lovers. Who isnt right? I had salted caramel truffle medium. Ice cream coma!!!! Delish

Me and my friends love it here! Its amazing

This place is amazing. It starts when I walked through the door & immediately smelled the fresh homemade waffles theyre making for the waffle cones. And they werent kidding about that ice cream. It was the best ice cream Ive had in years. There was dozens to choose from. I personnally chose the Salted Caramel Truffle. We also bought one of their large cookies to take home - outstanding as well. Their back patio is lovely, great use of the space. They are definitely an example of a bisiness doing everything right. I hope theyre around for a long time..

The ice cream is amazing. And the cookies are phenomenal. Mix the two and its unbeatable.

Such a nice place! The ice cream is so good, and the shop itself is so cute! This is definitely my favorite place to get ice cream with my friends & family.Try the cookies too! You won’t be disappointed, they’re so soft!!!

Love that is in my neighborhood..I had the cheese cake ice cream..love it 10/10❤

Stopped in with the wife and baby, and it was pretty good. Fresh cookies, really good bang for your buck, Ill be going back!

The worlds largest cookies, great ice cream, and a nice outdoor seating area.

A very unique like a 50s diner ice cream shop a soda shop happy theyre there well put a smile on your face dan

Best ice cream Ive had!!!

A very nice and clean place. You could definitely say it is a dimond in the ruff for ware it is located. Overall when you walk in you feel like you just stepped in to a ice-cream Parlor in 1955. The prices are good for the quality you are getting. The cookies might be a bit high in price. But then again I could see why. Once I bit in to one I wanted to buy every kind they had. I also got there 7s7s which is basically a blizzard but with twice the toppings mixed in with hot fudge at a lower cost then the Queen.

Good ice cream, good cookies!

The cookies and ice cream at this place is amazing! You gotta see it and try it all for yourself, super delicious.

Friendly staff, delicious ice cream, and AMAZING cookies. The atmosphere puts a modern twist on a classic ice cream parlor, and its just a fun place to be. Will definitely be coming back!!!

Great customer service! Great food especially the ice cream!!!!! Smells so great when you enter also!

I grew up in South Buffalo to walk Seneca St again and enjoy a fantastic ice cream with my Grandson. OMG! God bless South Buffalos REBIRTH! And all the men and woman of Hook and ladder development.

This place has AWESOME ice cream! Its Giffords from Maine, and its really good! Cant wait to go back there and try more delicious treats!

Amazing cookies. Hit the sweet tooth spot

A slice of heaven on Seneca Street

If your a fatboy and love cookies and ice cream like me... than come here ASAP!

Very friendly service and great ice cream.

Cute little spot!! People are great & the ice cream is yummy!!

Good selections of ice creams

The owner is amazing and the portions are huge. I love this place.

Very awesome

They should be ashame giving out those baby scoops of ice cream your better off buying u a $5 ice cream from the store u get more scoops 😊

The customer service was great and the cookies are super good!

Everything I have ever wanted 🤗

Great Ice cream... Gillfords if Maine and the price was reasonable. They have a very good selection of scoop flavored as well as soft serve, vanilla n chocolate which is not Gillfords. Cookies are delish w/a good assortment. Several booths inside to sit and enjoy and Plenty of outdoor room in fenced in backyard to do the same. Hope they remain in business for a long time to come... Revitalize Seneca St.,

Great ice cream

Delicious, creative and a kind atmosphere

Delicious! The best peppermint ice cream ive ever had!

Ive reviewed several dessert places in the Buffalo area, and this is the BEST. If you go, you have to try their Resses Cookie. Not expensive, hand sanitizing stations, outdoor and indoor seating.

Amazing!

Speedy service, Cookies & Ice Cream were delicious! Need to keep up more with cleaning fixtures though. Smudgy glass windows and doors could be off putting.

I was so disappointed the chocolate soft serve was broke, I said that’s all we like. Offered no substitutes or other options for the choose any 2 cookies and any soft serve. 16.50 and he wouldn’t even eat it because I settled for chocolate chip cookie and vanilla, he hates vanilla! Going to Tops for BOGO

All I have to say about this place is that it is AMAZING!!

I love this place !!! Thanks Hook and Ladder 👍

Sweet all around... atmosphere, cookies, icecream and counter girls!

Perfect little slice of happiness! Memories of long ago neighborhood ice cream shops! Love this !!! And the cookies are sooo good!!!!

Great cookies, great ice cream and cute environment!

Such a cute place with a ton of choices and great friendly service. I can’t believe how cute it is and would be a great date for couples of any age.