Anthony was terrific to work with. We brought in a whole bunch of coins and jewelry we had found in a safe when cleaning out my parents house. I didn’t feel rushed, all my questions were answered and pricing was clear and fair. He was honest about the junk stuff too, which I really appreciated. An overall good experience.

John was so wonderful to work with while selling some estate pieces from my Aunt. He is personable and friendly and really has a love for his work. He offers additional information and happily answers any questions. John makes you feel like family. I highly recommend John Michael’s!

A great local jeweler that has an extremely friendly and helpful staff. I brought in a watch for sizing that had very stubborn links. I was assisted immediately upon walking in and they were able to take out the links. I will continue to bring all of my watches to John Michaels

I recently sat with John to appraise a ton of items of my grandfathers. John took the time to review a list of the items ahead of time and was super responsive to me. We sat for nearly an hour going through each item (coins, jewelry, silver) and John described each with detail and helped me understand the value, demand, etc. Very fair, and sometimes even better prices when compared to online research. Would recommend to anyone. Very pleasant and interesting experience!

I sold jewelry and some other things here. They were very thorough yet pretty quick. I mostly dealt with Rachel, who was very friendly and helpful. John was as well. The price they offered me was above what my research led me to expect and the whole process was easy. I would definitely return and recommend to others.

Ive been selling my gold and silver coins at John Michaels for several years. John is totally straightforward, knowledgeable, and professional. There are never any games or tricks here.JMs is also a great place for collectors of sports memorabilia, baseball cards, and historical artifacts.

John was such a pleasure to deal with. We brought him my grandmothers wedding rings and he was more than happy to take a look at them and share all his vast knowledge about the stones. He sat with my fiancé and I for a long time discussing our plans for our ring and offering us wise suggestions. We ended up ordering a mounting through a reputable NY company that John was able to deal with to get us a great discount on our new engagement ring with my grandmothers stone in the center. He was thoughtful and kept us up to date throughout the whole process. We would gladly deal with him again anyway!

Could not be happier with the service we received. The ring turned out perfect for a reasonable price. If you are looking to buy an engagement ring this is the place. John worked with me to find the perfect setting and placed the diamond with precision and was kind and courteous enough to call me when the setting was complete so I could again surprise my fiancé. Top notch service.

Amazing place great selection of collectibles and the nicest pieces of antique jewlary you will ever see. My wife loved her engagement ring and wedding band

I had a GREAT experience buying an engagement ring from this store. Everybody there is very knowledgeable on all things jewelry. Helped me pick out the diamond and setting effortlessly and my now fiance loved the ring, it is beautiful. Thanks for the stressless experience!P.S.-The store is in a very convenient location and they have an awesome selection of vintage jewelry.

John and Michael will do whatever it takes for their customers to be happy. The friendly personable service they give, diverse knowledge and expertise in jewelry, antiques, collectables, memorabilia, and just about anything else will make your shopping experience an absolute pleasure! A gem of a store!