A little pricey but delicious. All the help was eager to serve. If the prices werent so high I would highly recommend them. But like I said their ice cream is good.

I love ice cream and this is one of my favorite places to just pull off the road and have some the staff here is cool there is a pretty good selection of flavors so if your in the are definitely stop by well worth it

Nothing to rave about, but expensive for mediocre ice cream. Place hasnt really good since it was Mrs Walkers years ago.

Always use this service i’d say one of the best ice cream trucks I’ve ever dealt with a soft serve on a spot excellent menu

Always enjoy the ice cream but recently the atmosphere has been off. Also ordered a large ice cream the last time I was there and It wasn’t even filled at all, very disappointing for almost 7$.

Always delicious!! I love that it is so close to home, friendly staff and always the #1 stop my family likes to get icecream at!

I like it but it seems to be a hit or miss. Past couple times it seem the icecream machines were overwork d so we got soupy icecream.

Walked in, walked out. There was a very heavy odor of sour milk. Figured Id rather not take my chances. My wife and kids still decided to order and most of it went to the garbage. So Im going to say dont waste your time.

Friendly staff, very accommodating. Had 2 ice cream cakes made for 2 different occasions, both were delicious and reasonably priced.

It was clean and ice cream was good. 4 people $20 seemed expensive seeing as we got 2 cones and 2 sundaes.

Ordered my ice cream through 3 different girls. I guess being that 3 different people took my order it got a little confusing for them. My medium plain vanilla was large and my large Sundae was med and had none of the 3 toppings I requested. I live over 5 miles away so I called. I didnt ask for a refund but I asked if maybe I could get a new ice cream next time I came in. I was told not unless I brought the product back. My ice cream was now made 20 mins ago and you want me to drive 10 mins back with melting ice cream for you to throw some toppings on it. How about not inconveniencing your guests and making it right the first time. And if we cant do that a full refund should be offered. I wasnt even asking for that. Thats no way to run a business. Especially to a customer who drives out of their way just to give you their business. I will never return. And neither will the 4 family members whos ice cream you screwed up and didnt make right.

Great ice cream, great staff

Fast, friendly service. Employees wearing masks. Fair price. Nice to have soft serve as its been a while. Just had a chocolate cone. It was good, but nothing special. Early afternoon on a holiday weekend and no crowd. ,🍦🕒

Their soft serve is somehow softer than soft serve. So good

Great place to get ice cream. Definitely better than DQ. Recommend to anyone.

This review is for new location in Lacey Township, its not listed yetEnjoyed my visit,will try other locations when I canI recommend

Bombin ice creams! Used to love the truck now its even better with the storefront!

Wasnt crowded and it was great ...the sales girls were so friendly.

So many great choices of ice cream here and the portions are very generous!

Party of for in on a Monday night, no other business in the store, greeted as soon as we walked in by the one counter girl. As the first order was being prepared another counter girl came over and took the next person in our party. The ice cream sundaes were quickly assembled with all the added specialties, the hot fudge brownie sundae had a hot brownie in it (extra credit there). The powder was reasonably priced and was enjoyed by all. Due to the covid restrictions in place, we had to eat outside, thankfully it was a nice evening. If youre craving Mister Softee ice cream and simply cant wait for the truck, i would recommend a visit to the store front, youll be happy that you did. P.S. ice cream calories dont count on Mondays and Tuesdays in the early fall so eat up!

Was ok but nothing special. I would rather take a ride and go to my favorite ice cream shops then go back.

Love this place so much. I was so happy to see an actual store front in Beachwood, NJ! I get all my ice cream cakes from them. They have such a nice welcoming staff and the place is always so clean too. Can’t say enough good things about this store front !

Delicious 😋 even my dog enjoys a vanilla soft severe every once in a while

Taste brings me back to 63 when the Mr softer truck would come down our street in Jersey City... Great all around.... I will be back here a lot.....

Great home made ice cream

The blueberry cobbler ice cream is amazing!

Grew up in the 70s with a Mister Softee truck patrolling the neighborhood every night in the summer -- its great to have a local Mister Softee shop nearby! Still as good as ever -- a little taste of the past!

Ive been wanting to go to Mr. Softee and I finally did. We walked in the two workers looked at us and continued their conversation without acknowledging us. After a few minutes they asked did we need help. I ordered a hot fudge brownie sundae. The young lady making it did not wear gloves while breaking up the brownie to put inside. I did enjoy the thin mint ice cream. Needless to say, that will be my first and last visit.

Today was my first time and let me say......wow thats awesome ice cream. The owners are a husband and wife team and they definitely have some creative ice cream flavors. I had the soft served strawberry and vanilla(so soft and creamy)fruity pebbles, pistachio, black raspberry and the pineapple/raspberry Dole cone which was so good. I will take pictures next time I order. This place is a must go to for dessert!

Mister Softee!!!! Finding this brick and mortar store was an adult dream come true lol! No more waiting for the truck like when I was a kid.

Staff was great! They showed my kids the flavors they would be more likely to enjoy! Very fast service

Weve been there numerous times, but probably wont be returning anytime soon as their employees are not enforcing the mask requirements for customers. When we went their last, there were a few customers not wearing masks and none of the employees said anything to them. We were not at all comfortable standing in line in a place that small. As far as the ice cream, it is good, but two sisters was better. They kept a lot of the ice creams and frozen treats from two sisters, but not everything.

I am so glad to have stumbled upon this place. I am new to the area and I was looking for a good ice cream place. This is our place now! Delicious ice cream and great flavors. Some favorites include fudge nut brownie, thin mint, Cookie Monster, etc. I am not a huge soft serve fan, but I was in the mood recently for a good soft serve cone with sprinkles, and their soft serve is very creamy, which I really love. Their butterfat content must be good, which as all true ice cream connoisseurs know, makes for creamier consistency. Yummmm!!!

Yummy old skool icecream

Childhood favorite now with a permanent shop. You no longer have to listen for that familiar jingle. Enjoyed a creamy soft serve black cat ice cream cone. For those unsure it is a chocolate cone. dipped part way in chocolate syrup with chocolate sprinkles and a cherry nose. Good service and reasonable prices.

Great flavors. Amazing customer service. We live 20 mins away & are closer to other ice cream shops BUT will def come back. new fave spot

They did not fill the cups they put way less ice cream basically gave me a small in a large cup. The ice cream sucks no taste or flavor at all Blueberry cheesecake tasted like frozen ice and blueberries and the party cake tasted like ice chips and sprinkles I could buy ice cream at shoprite that tastes better than this. I will stick with mrs. Walkers. If I could give zero stars I would but thats not an option so I had to give 1

Awesome always neat and clean

Two sisters ice cream was far better. I assume they got bought out and now its Mr. Softee instead. The recipes arent the same whatsoever. Take for example the banana ice cream, it used to have banana chunks and tasted natural and homemade. Now it tastes artificial, something youd find at a store.Aside from that, instead of closing down this listing and creating their own google post for Mr. Softee, they just stole theirs and their reviews. Sorry, youre not getting my 5 stars like that and youre not two sisters either. Time to find a new ice cream parlor.

Great Customer Service!

Best ice cream Ive ever had I got pistachio and a scoop of strawberry cheesecake !! DELICIOUSNESS highly recommend. EDIT: This place changed names and so did the ice cream. The strawberry cheese cake taste like frozen whipped cream and had ice chunks in it. Flavor not the same anymore unfortunately.

Excellent ice cream.. just like I remembered it as a kid. Thanks for coming to the boardwalk.

Mr. Softee Ice Cream have pretty good ice cream and service. I went here not realizing that Two Sisters was sold to another person. I went in there to get my daughters birthday cake like I do. The new owner was very accommodating when I told him that my daughter has autism and has to have her ice cream cake a certain way. He had no problem with the request - and I will have to say the mint chocolate chip ice cream was delicious! My daughter loved her cake. The following month ordered another cake on short notice. That cake came out just as yummy! Thank you!

Place was clean workers were helpful and friendly. Loved it.

Very good brings back memories

Love that they have black and white shakes on the menu . The ice cream is good. Loved the Cookie Monster!

We moved into the area a few years ago and tried another ice cream shop not far from Two Sisters but after coming here there was no turning back as Two Sisters is by far the best ice cream in the area.They have an excellent variety of ice cream flavors to choose from with plenty of toppings to add if you so choose. Besides your every day ice cream aka cones, sundaes, shakes etc. they make excellent cakes. You can choose between the pre made cakes or special order one to your liking which we usually do and only need to give them notice ahead of time of 2-3days.The workers are all very friendly and you never leave here unsatisfied!

We have been going here for a few years now. By far the best family owned ice cream shop around. Everything is always fresh and there are plenty of options including sugar free! Everyone is very friendly attentive. You never leave here unsatisfied we cant wait to go back and get choco tacos! Thank you for the great quality ice cream!

Who doesnt love Mister Softee?!?!Not only the best ice cream, but the girls who work here are so sweet and patient!

The PB&J shake was awesome !! Just like eating the sandwich without the bread. Delicious !!

This is my absolute favorite ice cream stop! The lovely ladies working are always super friendly! A big plus is all of the ice cream is homemade, and definitely high quality! My go to is the chocolate milkshake, which for some reason, is better than anywhere else! I really hope they dont go anywhere any time soon!

Had an ice cream soda from there yesterday, the worst I ever had. Can of flat coke warm by the way, with horrible tasting soft chocolate ice cream. If you do not know how to make admit it. By the way no gloves no masks by personnel. Should be shut down.

I love their fat free, no sugar added vanilla frozen yogurt. Its really good. 👍😎 My husband and I are diabetic, they have about four delicious flavors that we can have for a treat. Nice ice cream parlor, they do cakes too and have alot of different ice cream flavors and novelty ice cream.

Grow up with Mr Softee!! So excited to have one near my home town... Seeing the truck tonight gave me the chills!!! Brought back so many memories....and even the first lick my taste buds remembered...Welcome home Mr Softee!!!!

Good thick shakes

Good quality icecream from a nice clean local place

No Mr. Softy. Very good ice cream. Front entrance and parking dimly lit

The best home made ice cream hands down. My favorite is the peanut butter cup its fully loaded..

This is now Miss Mindys Ice Cream and its DEEELISCIOUS!!!! Family owned and run.The ice cream is home made with love.My favorite is the waffle cone nacho chips with Tire Tracks and Chocolate Peanut Butter ice cream!!!Very nice staff. Its worth the wait in line for this treat.

Best ice-cream in the area! Great selection of flavors! Right off Route 9. Easy in and out with free parking. Friendly service. Some tables. Still great!!!

I love when I come into this business! I might be a frequent shopper but no matter who is working they remember who I am and have a general idea of what my family is going to order! I love that it is family owned and operated, most importantly the young staff they hire every season are respectful and professional!

Pretty good. But sundaes are in a milkshake cup and just not the same as a regular sundae cup.

Polite staff and amazing ice cream choices

Absolutely delicious ice cream! Super friendly staff. Open every day except Christmas!

We love it here. We go all the time to where they know what we are going to order and question when one family member is not there

Flavorless ice cream ... Stale toppings. No good.

I love the ice cream and the service here. They make great milkshakes and we always get our birthday cakes here. Highly recommended.

Yummy

Amazing ice cream. Was not sure when I first saw it but it proved me wrong.Great place for homemade ice cream.

Definitely a five-star place, off the Beaten Track with phenomenal ice cream. Mrs. Walkers and Richs ice cream do not stay open all year, but they do.A vast array of different flavors with overstuffed ice cream sandwiches that would blow your mind check it out.......

Amazing product extremely fresh. Welcoming service and cheap prices compared to other competitors.

Havent gone yet .this wknd.lol

The ice cream is rich and creamy and we love the staff!

Very good ice cream

Good prices and great ice cream

Nasty womanNow they dont get my buisness air was rude and sarcastic.Prices go up like everything in the world. Nice costumer service 🙌😡 Ill go to ritas

Really cozy shop with great ice cream and great service. The prices were wonderful as well.

The best ice cream ever in the people that work there or very nice and pleasant and I always got a smile on her face

Went in tonight for 2 lg sundaes. Was given to me in 12oz maybe 16oz cups (drink cups). Had barely any ice cream. Cup wasnt even filled half way. Waste of money!

Cozy little yummy ice cream store...I would go again.

Third time Ive gone in there with a mask on only to see customers allowed in a very small space without a mask. Please put a sign on your door that masks are now mandatory in stores!

Always nice and ready to help, great quality ice cream

Ice cream was good. I just think there are better choices in the area

Everytime we go we have a great experience! This place rocks, the ice cream and selection blow the competition away.

Great ice cream

Its much better than Sundaes!!!! And wide variety of ice creams!!!

Love this place!!! Awesome Ice cream and great staff!

Quite delicious, just wish there were dairy free options.

Always fresh homemade ice cream, good variety of flavors. Love the flying saucers mmmmmmmmm.

Best ice cream we have ever had! Thanks

My favorite ice cream in the TR area!

Now called Two Sisters Ice Cream, this shop has the best ice cream. Try the chocolate marshmallow.

Excellent variety ice cream lovers paradise!🤗

Really good 👍 but kinda pricey.

Homemade Ice cream at its best.

Nice people work there and the ice cream is awesome.

The Best Ice Cream.. I LOVED it

Nice quaint Place homemade ice cream no complaints

OMG The Worst Ice cream ever! I Was Sick For Hours after Having a Coffee Milk Shake! I Think they have ruined Coffee Milk Shake s for Me!!!!!

Great placd