Nice staff and delicious donuts! The donuts are definitely bigger than your typical donuts shop. Tried their Boston cream and a strawberry cheesecake, and both were yummy! All others looked delicious also.

Delicious, and gigantic cake like donuts. Place an order a few days early, and those beautiful things are ready when you pick them up. First time inside the store. I didnt have the time to explore.

Ridiculous donuts. A little pricey compared to a DD but you get an enormous, almost miniature cake of a donut. And every one I’ve tried so far was crazy good. This place is a hidden gem in Bay Shore.

Lets just say they are the best donuts I’ve had and continue to indulge as time goes by. Each time i have a nofodoco donut, my day is complete. The best thing that could have happened was them opening it in bayshore so its closer to home! Recommended to any other donut lovers. Worth the trip everytime. Just make sure you call before you leave cause i was disappointed once driving 25 minutes to find out they were closed/sold out for the day. Also emailed and got no response which was a disappointment as well. Other than that, the quality of donuts are exceptional!

Cinnamon Coffee- Yummy.Key Lime Pie- it was a hit.Honey lavender- I liked but not my favStrawberry Shortcake- my favorite, loved the freshnessOreo- Wish it was filledBoston Creme- Good, wish it had more filling!Paid $4.00 each donutMy only comment would be that I enjoy when both the doughnut base and the toppings are different for each doughnut. Having a variety of say: old fashioned style, brioche, filled, etc.Overall the trip was good. I enjoyed my cold brew coffee. Only a few people inside ordering and the service was pleasant/fast. I used my Apple Pay and was on my way!

Delicious soft Donuts. If you are looking for a good Donut make sure to stop by.

Holy cow. These donuts are incredible. The environment of NOFODOCO is friendly and welcoming and their donuts are beyond amazing. Felt like Homer Simpson drooling over this box of miracles.

These were the best donuts I have ever had. Denise was so sweet and made my day today. Will definitely be back for more.

Donuts were banging. Also the customer service was amazing. They were helpful and gave good suggestions to what donuts to buy!!

Donuts are great nice flavor at the bottom they are bigger then my fist haha. But donuts are great!

The best donuts one long island. Hands down 💪 sooooo fluffffyyy and massive!! Head over early for more to choose from 😍

Wow what a nice addition to downtown Bay Shore. I have had donuts from this location four times already. My two favorite donuts are the Cookies & Cream and Caramel Coffee Cake flavors. The Donuts are huge and pack a lot of flavor.My only negative is the price however you get what you pay for here. If you want cheap donuts go to Dunkin then. What you get here is quality ingredients and a chance to support your local business!

Donuts are huge fluffy and delicious. I usually like more plain donuts but the flavors aren’t overly sweet! The girl who helped me was so nice. I live in the city and I think these are better than most of the gourmet places near me

Yummy donuts. 🍩😋

First of all these donuts are huge! Made so fresh and a lot of variety. The girls at the counter were sweet and the customer service was pleasing.. I will be returning

Bright, vibrant, hip atmosphere with friendly staff. I love the donut themed decoration. its fun and inviting.now onto the main attraction: the donuts. they had a good variety of donuts when I arrived and some very appetizing flavors. after much debate, I opted for oatmeal cookie, cookies and cream, earl grey, black raspberry filled and the OG glazed.the black raspberry filled was surprisingly good and delightfully messy. the filling-to-dough ratio is high, so the sweet/tart compote oozed out with one bite. there were good bits of fruit though I could have stood just a bit more solids. still very good.the earl grey was tasty. the tea flavor was subtle but present and the icing wasnt overly sweet. the cookies and cream was much what I expected. the oatmeal cookie, although good, was disappointing in that the oatmeal flavor was over powered by the icing. maybe less icing or more intense flavor in the cookie bits.lastly, the OG glazed was simply delicious. a good glaze over a soft, fluffy doughnut.as I recall, there were no cake doughnuts. so if thats your preference you may be out of luck. but check ahead because their offerings change about every 2 weeks.

The service was great and the donuts are soooo good I would hurt someone for those donuts!!!!!!!

Nofodoco is so goo I cant resist going on my birthday every year this year I came to the Bayshore location this year and was very impressed I am so happy they now have a location up island and closer to me

The donuts are huge and surprisingly delicious. It was a wonderful change from eating Dunkin for so many years. Heres to many more successful years

Amazing donuts that will leave you stuffed, the boston creams are my favorite!

The oreo doughnut is pretty good but they gave my grandpa the wrong doughnut after him saying 3 times he wanted cinnamon

I had a Boston cream and the filling was lacking. Perhaps it was an isolated issue ... other than that cute place and hefty sized donuts

This place has very creative doughnuts. I highly recommend stopping by.

So good! Donuts arent heavy they have great classic flavors and the Bayshore location has started to bring in some specialty flavors for fall! Loving having a location nearby! Pictured is their #makeitbasic pumpkin spice donut and iced latte!

OMG... OMG... OMG! Death by donuts. Expensive but worth it when youre having company or just for some special day... Like a Friday! 😂

The doughnuts were tasty, the service was lackluster.Located in the heart of Main st. Bay Shore, parking could be difficult. Limited street parking which is metered. There is a lot behind Tullulahs restaurant down the side street which should have spots available (which is also metered).Inside, the shop is so cute and very clean.The prices are part of the reason Im taking a star off. I just cant see paying $4 a doughnut as a usual thing. Its very expensive for a dozen. Almost $40 quite high. Yes, the doughnuts are packed with cream/jelly etc., but its still costly.Youre also at mercy of the place. The flavors depend on what they make that day. There is never a 100% guarantee that the doughnut you like will be made that day. They also could sell out.The service wasnt very friendly. I felt that for the amount Im paying, the service should have been better.The doughnuts were very fresh. I tried a Linzer Tart, Chocolate Fudge Brownie, Boston Cream, Caramel Crumb, and Kettle Corn. My favorites were the chocolate fudge & linzer tart. All of the doughnuts were tasty. The Boston Cream was huge and filled with so much cream!Overall, the doughnuts were delicious but the prices and service were disappointing.

Smoothest nitro cold brew on the island... and they also have great doughnuts

Its ONLY DONUT HEAVEN! Light, fluffy, incredibly delicious choices and the classics (glazed, chocolate frosted, sugar cinnamon, etc.) are perfect. Ive heard that if you live a good life and are nice to people, when you die and go to heaven they give you NoFoDoCo donuts for your first breakfast. Just to make sure you know youre in heaven.

Just stopped by to visit my friend and buy some donuts!! and omg, these donuts are amazing!! i completely recommend❤️❤️

Killer donuts, great service. Perfect if you live on the south shore and want a great donut.

Great doughnuts- they manage to stay fresh and chewy (I like them chewy) even overnight. Even a pretty good value @$4 each. Only turnoff was that I asked if chocolate could be put on a raspberry jam donut and was turned down. Then moments later I overheard the same staff telling a customer that the doughnuts arrive in the morning and they are dressed up in the store, so Im puzzled why they wouldnt accomodate this wish. Still looking forward to going back.

I dunno how this place gets a 5 star rating when it grabbed my attention of that to try them out. Simply overpriced for an excessive amount of fluffy dough and lack luster flavor or taste. It looks amazing in the glass case and your like for the price it must be amazing and then the DISAPPOINTMENT HAPPENS!!!Im giving you an honest review I drove half-hr to check these out !!

Doughnut’s are amazing, great size and high quality ingredients made to perfection.

Donuts are HUGE and so unique! Love coming here for my sugar fix!

The Donuts was great but on a day to day basis the Variety was small👍🏾☕👍🏾

Its always so clean and the employees are so kind! These donuts are the best Ive ever had!

These donuts were delicious and huge! Wish I would have taken pics of the other. But since I know I will be back I will update for my next trip!

Great donuts great flavors but a bit pricey

My experience at No Fo Do Co was outstanding. The service was amazing! Everyone in there was so friendly. The quality of the donuts themselves were incredible! I rate this place a 10 out of 10!

Delicious 😋 is all I can say!!!

Nofodoco just makes me happy :) the donuts are always delicious and just something to get excited about. The staff is always friendly as well

The donuts are very pretty and huge, but the taste of the chocolate was off. The chocolate didnt melt in my fingers on a hot day, which was strange, and makes me suspect they add additives that affect the flavor.

Service was superb by the staff. Donuts were definitely grade A. The frosting, filling, toppings were all on point. The pumpkin latte I ordered required a second cup after the first sip.

Delicious donuts

Great donuts. Super friendly staff. Very clean store.

The best donut

Huge donuts. Donuts are very good.

Doughnut as Big as your face. A must stop and eat place.

Cute store but the donut I got, pumpkin cheesecake, was way too sweet. Basically all sugar I couldnt eat it.

Great variety, freshly made and giant doughnuts! Make sure to stop for a dozen (or two) if youre in the area!

High price for a less than average big donut. They will not see me again

The people are just as amazing as the donuts which are literally life changing. Love the new location.

This place has amazing, delicious donuts. I definitely recommend this place.

Never been to the Mattituck location but tried this location today which recently opened up. The staff were really nice and friendly. Doughnuts are one of the best I’ve had and are some of the biggest doughnuts I’ve ever seen.

My daughter love the donuts there even I love them too

A bit disappointing. While the staff is friendly and the donuts are pretty, theyre all essentially the same base donut with different toppings- which go stale relatively quickly.

Staff were friendly and the donuts were great!

Doughnuts were great, staff friendly as well

OMG so delicious

Had the lemon donut. Im sorry but it was nothing special. I have been wanting to get here for months. A bit disappointed.

Big donuts real good

Best donuts ever.

The yummiest of all places

Good food but too expensive

Yummy

Best donuts I ever had. Both the classic Boston Cream and the original Coffee Cake donut were amazing. Yes they cost more than DD, but then Peter Luger costs more than McDonalds. You get what you pay for.

A sweet and delicious experience.

Good af donuts